6 ms·
Rediscovered Medieval Manuscript Offers New Twist on Arthurian Legend
- arbitrage 5y agoThe part of the article that describes the new (old?) twist is all the way at the end: The team found that the account differed from other versions of the story in several key ways. A sexual encounter between Merlin and Viviane, also known as the Lady of the Lake, is “slightly toned-down,” Tether tells the Guardian. She adds: > In most manuscripts of the better known [version], Viviane casts a spell whereby three names are written on her groin that prevent Merlin from sleeping with her. In several manuscripts of the lesser-known version, these names are written on a ring instead. In our fragments, this is taken one step further: the names are written on a ring, but they also prevent anyone speaking to her. So the Bristol Merlin gets rid of unchaste connotations by removing reference to both Viviane’s groin and the idea of Merlin sleeping with her. Merlin’s image has changed dramatically over the centuries. In more modern versions of the King Arthur legends, he is a wise advisor to the king. In the earliest iterations of the story, however, Campbell says he was a “morally dubious” magical seer or even a “creepy little boy [whose] father is a devil.”
- mistrial9 5y agothere are plenty of folk-tale rewrites that cast "magic" people as morally dubious, creepy and yes, servants of the Devil.. who wrote those? any agenda detectable?
- Bayart 5y agoPagan literature has plenty of creepy magical and divine beings. Just look at the Odyssey.
- pdabbadabba 5y agoThe Norse (and especially Icelandic) sagas also demonstrate this pretty starkly, and are from a related tradition to the Arthurian legends. In those, people with magical powers very clearly tend to be portrayed as creepy weirdos--and also, for whatever reason, tend to be from the Hebrides.
- krapp 5y agoOf course, "creepy" is relative and contextual. The way we interpret the morality of the ancient Greek gods and other such beings is not necessarily the way their native cultures would have seen them. Zeus being a profligate shapeshifting rapist was not a big deal in a society where women were granted the same degree of consent as cattle.
- exolymph 5y agoThis is just normal. > In nearly every documented society, people believe that some misfortunes are caused by malicious group mates using magic or supernatural powers. Here I report cross-cultural patterns in these beliefs and propose a theory to explain them. Using the newly created Mystical Harm Survey, I show that several conceptions of malicious mystical practitioners, including sorcerers (who use learned spells), possessors of the evil eye (who transmit injury through their stares and words), and witches (who possess superpowers, pose existential threats, and engage in morally abhorrent acts), recur around the world. I argue that these beliefs develop from three cultural selective processes: a selection for intuitive magic, a selection for plausible explanations of impactful misfortune, and a selection for demonizing myths that justify mistreatment. Separately, these selective schemes produce traditions as diverse as shamanism, conspiracy theories, and campaigns against heretics — but around the world, they jointly give rise to the odious and feared witch. I use the tripartite theory to explain the forms of beliefs in mystical harm and outline 10 predictions for how shifting conditions should affect those conceptions. Societally corrosive beliefs can persist when they are intuitively appealing or they serve some believers' agendas. https://www.gwern.net/docs/sociology/2021-singh.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/sociology/2021-singh.pdf
- a1369209993 5y ago> any agenda detectable? Yes. It's a pro-manipulative-psychopath agenda. People with great social influence - priests, politicians/nobles, pillars of the community - by definition rely on soft power and social status. People with inherent power of their own - wizards, superheroes, or more mundanely scientists or hackers - are able to ignore or at least resist social power, and are consequently a threat. To the extent that that threat is seen as credible (and magic users were historically seen as credible), social power will be deployed to vilify and discredit them. (Of course, in practice a lot of it is just cultural inertia/established narrative tropes from previous cases.)
- krapp 5y agoThat's syncretism - what happened almost every time Christianity began to take over a pagan culture. The former gods/spirits, etc. become recast as demonic or malevolent, and of course any "occult" practices (which were, formerly, simply religious practices) are viewed as Satanic practice and witchcraft. This is partly due to attempts by Christian authorities to de-legitimize the former religion, but also attempts to preserve the former culture and its religious practices in a new context. Norse mythology is a particularly interesting example, because all we have of it is post-Christian retellings, and many parts of it (like Baldr's death and resurrection) seem an awful lot like Christianity with the serial numbers filed off.
- jkestner 5y agoA Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court has my canonical Merlin. Something of a jealous Rasputin.
- mathattack 5y agoDo recall the context… The Arthurian legends are not a story with sole authorship, like the Lord of the Rings. These are stories twisted and told by many different people. Perhaps the modern analogy is Spider-Man. Within Marvel there are many different varieties, and then you add on the fan driven content… For those deeply interested in different takes on Arthur, Steinbeck [0] took a stab at it too. This sent me down a long Arthurian rabbit hole. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Acts_of_King_Arthur_and_His_Noble_Knights https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Acts_of_King_Arthur_and_...
- thaumasiotes 5y agoSome modern fan-driven content: https://www.arthurkingoftimeandspace.com/ https://www.arthurkingoftimeandspace.com/
- samizdis 5y agoGood grief. I had no idea that Steinbeck had written an Arthurian tale - and based on Malory, to boot. I am so looking forward to reading that. Thanks for the information.
- sparky_z 5y agoJust wait until you find out about his werewolf murder mystery :) https://www.npr.org/2021/05/28/1001309335/a-young-john-steinbecks-unpublished-werewolf-novel-isnt-going-to-print https://www.npr.org/2021/05/28/1001309335/a-young-john-stein...
- dash2 5y agoBig shout out to the Morte d'Arthur. I read it last year and at first found it hard to get into. There's tons of repetitive tournaments and jousting... the Marvel analogy is not wrong, it's a bit like a comic book. But gradually the characters get into your head, and the final conflict between Lancelot and Arthur really hits hard.
- mistrial9 5y agodon't forget A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court ;-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Connecticut_Yankee_in_King_Arthur%27s_Court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Connecticut_Yankee_in_King_A...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- all2 5y agoThis is one of my favorites. Merlin in this always cracks me up. Also the protagonists learned knowledge is fascinating to me. The guy goes and creates a bunch of stuff from scratch and knows all the bits that go into the things. I always wonder if my education had been lacking, just because of this story.
- javajosh 5y agoMy sense is that there was a sweet spot in the late 18th to mid-20th century when modern(ish) things were still built by human hands, mostly using simple tools, so people could learn to build (and repair) those things for themselves. That accessibility was partly recreated in the 80's with the PC, but things have shrunk down and become hermetically sealed with fewer ports, switches and physical buttons. And memory density has increased to the point where even sophisticated users will never understand all the software running on their machine. Cars have become far more complex than their mid-20th century counterparts, to the point where few people even check or change oil. Americans are born and bred these days to be administrators of some kind, where all physical and digital goods and services can be purchased on the virtual open market behind touch-sensitive glass. If that glass breaks, you call a (low status) worker to fix it; if something behind the glass breaks, you complain to a (slightly higher status) worker to fix it. You yourself don't do or make anything - you allocate funds and then, at most, measure progress and outcomes. Such an admin does not make a usable character like that in Twain. In fact, neither would either of the two low status workers, since they only "make" at the tip of an enormous world-spanning supply chain. You'd need to be a machinist, metallurgist or chemist with an interest in low-tech methods. Pretty rare.
- PeterCorless 5y agoOkay... So former Arthurian publisher here. For folks who are semi-familiar with the canon of existing literature, what they found corresponds with the well-known "Story of Merlin" from the Lancelot-Vulgate Cycle. Like, we already have this story in print. [Look up "Lancelot-Grail: 2. The Story of Merlin: The Old French Arthurian Vulgate and Post-Vulgate in Translation (Lancelot-Grail: The Old French Arthurian Vulgate and Post-Vulgate in Translation"] and get yourself a modern English translated paperback version of this "lost" Arthurian story.] There is nothing particularly new or unique here apart from the fact that this is a new copy of what we already know. The article points out that if anything, this is a slightly Bowdlerized version of the already-extant story that took out the spicy parts about how the Lady of the Lake cast a spell on her lady bits to prevent the horn-dog Merlin from getting at them.