3 ms·
> Did MIT study whether the "inattentive" drivers had higher accident rates and fatality rates than other drivers? > That should be the question. Why should t
by wolverine876 5y ago
> Did MIT study whether the "inattentive" drivers had higher accident rates and fatality rates than other drivers?
> That should be the question.
Why should that be the question? If the feature is dangerous, removing it will improve safety. If there are more dangerous features, we can remove those too.
- bracketslash 5y agoThat should be the question because we don’t know if the drivers being inattentive actually lead to anything bad happening, I think. If the drivers are inattentive but there is no downside to that, then it doesn’t really matter.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoBecause maybe the Tesla features improve safety despite increasing inattentiveness
- ghufran_syed 5y agoBecause we need to define "dangerous" - the authors and you are making an assumption that what they call "inattention" is the same as "dangerous" whereas the comment you are replying to is questioning that assumption. If the link between "inattention" and accident rates is strong, then measuring that should be equivalent. In medicine there is a concept of measuring disease-oriented outcomes instead of patient-oriented outcomes, because it's easier to show an intervention affects the disease-oriented outcomes, and much harder to show a change in patient-oriented outcomes. So for example, a disease-oriented ourcome for hip-replacement surgery would be "range of movement after 2 weeks", patient-oriented might be "can go up a flight of stairs" The analogy here seems relevant.