4 ms·
> The point of this study is not to shame Tesla, but rather to advocate for driver attention management systems that can give drivers feedback in real time or a
by rvz 5y ago
> The point of this study is not to shame Tesla, but rather to advocate for driver attention management systems that can give drivers feedback in real time or adapt automation functionality to suit a driver’s level of attention. Currently, Autopilot uses a hands-on-wheel sensing system to monitor driver engagement, but it doesn’t monitor driver attention via eye or head-tracking.
Precisely. I said this before and now this study supports my previous points even further [0]. Using the wheel to monitor driver attention is not even close to good enough to determine if the driver is paying attention or not. Comma.ai seems to be able to implement eye-tracking for their driver monitoring system.
I'm quite surprised that Tesla continues to lack such a system to monitor the drivers eyes on the road when they are behind the wheel especially when the user is using autopilot or not.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28208921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28208921
- Lendal 5y agoEspecially since there's a hardware camera built in to every Tesla, right at the driver's eye level. I'd rather have that system than the wheel sensor. Accidentally applying too much force on the steering wheel disables the autopilot while too little force doesn't register. It's annoying, trying to get the amount of Goldilocks force just right. But the eyes don't lie.
- elif 5y agopro-tip: either of the scrollwheels, volume adjustment or speed adjustment, are considered driver inputs. I typically go +1 kph, -1 kph its not even noticable
- romwell 5y agoPro-tip #2: if you insert the belt buckle into the clip before getting into the seat, the system thinks you have buckled up, it's not even noticeable
- elif 5y agoI guess i have to explain that applying torque to the wheel is less safe than adjusting your volume. My tip is a safety tip, your joke doesn't really apply?
- Lendal 5y agoYou're talking about defeating a safety feature in an unsafe manner. I'm talking about how to let the car know I'm paying attention without inadvertently disabling autopilot in the process. Not comparable at all.
- romwell 5y ago>You're talking about defeating a safety feature in an unsafe manner You're this close to getting my point
- nemothekid 5y ago>I'm quite surprised that Tesla continues to lack such a system to monitor the drivers eyes on the road I'm not sure if it's documented anywhere but I think the 2021 Tesla models do this [1]. That said, I'm not sure if this is enough - this is the same issue Google faced which led them to believe they had to go L4 of bust. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/5/27/22457430/tesla-in-car-camera-driver-monitoring-system https://www.theverge.com/2021/5/27/22457430/tesla-in-car-cam...
- sschueller 5y agoWe should absolutely shame Tesla. Their marketing is selling "Full Self Driving" and have many times in the past hinted that autopilot is something it isn't. Elon claiming that your car will be a RoboTaxi in - 2 years also doesn't help and makes people think autopilot must be quite good. How is a regular Joe supposed to know?
- moduspol 5y agoThe multiple warnings and the dialogue that explicitly requires confirmation might be a good hint. But I think we all know this problem hasn't materialized in crash data, because if it did, that's what we'd be talking about. Instead it's just more FUD about the names of features, some of which are explicitly not yet delivered.
- romwell 5y agoThe problem didn't materialize in crash data, eh? It absolutely did. Why we're not talking about it is another issue. https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2020/02/25/ntsb-teslas-autopilot-steered-model-x-into-highway-median-causing-fatal-mountain-view-crash https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2020/02/25/ntsb-teslas-a...
- moduspol 5y agoAre Tesla's cars with Autopilot involved in fatal crashes at a notably higher rate than comparable cars? If the answer were "yes," you wouldn't be pointing me to anecdotes. You'd be pointing me to that data. The lack of that data is why, despite years, hundreds of thousands of vehicles, and millions upon millions of miles driven, people are still blaming the names of features. It's time to move on. Over 100 people die in the US per day in traffic accidents. How many years need to pass before a handful of anecdotes and speculation doesn't pass as valid criticism?
- stefan_ 5y agoYes, why do we care that Boeing withheld crucial information about the MCAS? Is two crashed planes a lot compared to other plane models? Why do we determine the root cause for every crashed plane, there aren't a lot of those anymore? There is statistics, and then there is addressing obvious design flaws. The latter is worth doing a lot more than the former.
- falcolas 5y ago> I'm quite surprised that Tesla continues to lack such a system to monitor the drivers eyes on the road when they are behind the wheel especially when the user is using autopilot or not. Perhaps we shouldn't expect that of people? If you've taken the vast burden of driving off their minds, we should accept that human nature means they'll stop paying attention to driving. That, however, explicitly implies that automation needs to be much better before it can be used.
- elif 5y ago> I'm quite surprised that Tesla continues to lack such a system to monitor the drivers eyes on the road when they are behind the wheel especially when the user is using autopilot or not. You are surprised for no cause. Tesla uses exactly that system. https://www.notateslaapp.com/software-updates/version/2021.4.15.11/release-notes https://www.notateslaapp.com/software-updates/version/2021.4...
- elif 5y agosince i'm being downvoted for this?? here's a link describing it?? https://www.notateslaapp.com/news/565/tesla-rolling-out-driver-monitoring-system-to-vehicles-with-radar https://www.notateslaapp.com/news/565/tesla-rolling-out-driv...
- rvz 5y agoDid you not realize that the driver in the image has just tricked the so-called 'Driver monitoring system' with a static image? Just like how lots of drivers have fooled the wheel sensors? I was expecting this to be more advanced than Comma.ai, but after seeing this, I'm even more disappointed with Tesla. What if the driver is using autopilot when they are driving at night? It appears that there is no night vision in the car cabin cameras of this system. [0] That means that it can't determine the driver's attentiveness when you are driving in the night; the most dangerous time to drive. Therefore, this system is unreliable and very dangerous and it already can be fooled. I'm afraid that this implementation is still not good or safe enough to use. [0] https://insideevs.com/news/529788/tesla-driver-monitoring-camera-test/ https://insideevs.com/news/529788/tesla-driver-monitoring-ca...