5 ms·
Each of those "firebombings" were conducted by 50+ B-29 bombers. When you see so many bombers show up on radar, you dispatch the fighters, you know things are a
by dragontamer 5y ago
Each of those "firebombings" were conducted by 50+ B-29 bombers. When you see so many bombers show up on radar, you dispatch the fighters, you know things are about to happen.
When you see a SINGLE B-29 bomber, you ignore it. Its just a scout, and one bomber can't do much damage... Until Hiroshima happened. Its unbelievable: the "rules" of the war changed overnight, in a dramatic way that no one in the Japanese army could have possibly imagined. Every __SINGLE__ bomber "scout" could in fact be, the next nuclear bomb.
Japan didn't have the resources to fight against singular bombers anymore. They focused only on the groups of bombers. At this point, it was clear that their air-force was soundly defeated.
- Ericson2314 5y agoI don't think the Japanese was defending very well against the firebombs either by that point. > Japan didn't have the resources to fight against singular bombers anymore. They focused only on the groups of bombers. At this point, it was clear that their air-force was soundly defeated. It doesn't really make sense that it is easier to take down 10 bombers than 1, does it? It sounds like you mean the hypothetical where as many bombers were each sent individual to nuke as many cities that would be harder to defend against, because any bombers that got through would do so much more damage. So it's important to differential between potential destruction and actual destruction. The firebombings did incontrovertibly more damage, and after the war both governments had reason to not emphasize this.
- tehjoker 5y agoCurtis LeMay once commented that if the Axis had won he would have been tried for war crimes. Yea, the fire bombing was truly insane. A fictional account based on the author's experience of what occurred in Dresden, Germany can be found in Slaughterhouse V by Kurt Vonnegut. https://www.toptenz.net/brutal-facts-about-general-curtis-lemay.php https://www.toptenz.net/brutal-facts-about-general-curtis-le... This is not to say anything nice about the Axis powers, but more to dispel the illusion that the American military were some kind of heroic force.
- btilly 5y agoIt doesn't really make sense that it is easier to take down 10 bombers than 1, does it? If you fire an imprecise weapon at a group of 10 bombers, your odds of hitting one of them can be up to 10x what it is if the same weapon fired at a single bomber. If you have limited ammunition, it is therefore sensible to wait for the group of 10 before firing. So it's important to differential between potential destruction and actual destruction. The firebombings did incontrovertibly more damage, and after the war both governments had reason to not emphasize this. Yeah. The USA invented a weapon (napalm) specifically intended to target the poorest neighborhoods in Japan. And those neighborhoods were so vulnerable exactly because the Japanese government didn't care about the people living there. It was much safer to talk about how big and threatening nuclear bombs were.
- dragontamer 5y agoI don't believe that Japan had limited ammunition quite yet. But they had limited ace pilots and limited fighters at this point of the war. (The strategic bombs targeted airbases, airplane factories, and radar. The longer the bombings continued, the weaker the airforce got).
- dragontamer 5y ago> It doesn't really make sense that it is easier to take down 10 bombers than 1, does it? In 1944, these were largely "strategic" bombers: who had more range than our fighters. I believe they were unescorted (our fighters / carriers simply didn't have enough range yet to provide assistance). These large "superfortress" bombers may have had machine gun defenses, but they couldn't dodge or dogfight. They were sitting ducks (albeit at higher altitudes than Japanese aircraft could follow, but these superfortresses weren't made for air-superiority... not at all). This means that if a Japanese fighter / interceptor was most efficient vs these strategic bombing runs. Once you shot down one bomber, you're already to shoot down a 2nd or 3rd. Your most efficient use of fighters was therefore against groups of bombers. ---------- Its not about the "difficulty" of the task, and more about the "efficiency" of the task. One Ace pilot could kill 2 or 3 bombers during the defense of a city. But if only 1-bomber "scout" were going somewhere, its just not worth your ace pilot's time or energy. The best they could do is shoot down just one enemy bomber.
- vkou 5y ago450 B-29s were lost in the pacific theatre (Only 300 of which to enemy action). They were credited for shooting down 714 fighters, with 456 probably destroyed, and 770 damaged. Given their heavy defensive armaments, I would not describe that as a 'sitting duck'. As Japan lost the ability to actually put planes in the air, B-29 guns started getting stripped out, because they were no longer necessary. Yes, they were big targets, but they were also flying quickly, at high altitudes. A fighter only carries so much ammunition, can quickly expend it, and has poor accuracy when shooting at a distant, fast-moving target. Due to the fuel shortages, available fighter loiter time was very low, so it doesn't get more than one, maybe two chances in a sortie to even take a shot at a B-29. And even if some of its shots hit, it's still quite likely that the bomber will make it back home.
- danielvf 5y agoJapan's ability to defend itself from air attacks was essentially over before the mass firebombing attacks even began. Before the first firebomb raid the US removed all but one machine gun from each B-29's in order to carry more bombs, judging correctly that the Japanese defenses were weak enough.
- dragontamer 5y agoIt sounds like the removal of guns was not only about bombs, but also about speed. If you got shot at early, you simply drop your bombs (maybe over rural farmland) and hit the engines as hard as you can. You wanted to fall into the part of the sea where the US-Navy still controlled the area. The bombers were flighting high enough that even if they were shot down... there was a chance of being rescued after a crash landing. But the crash landing absolutely had to be outside of the control of the Japanese. As such, more engine power, less guns, more bombs. Drop the bombs if attacked unexpectedly, and drift towards the Navy. If all goes well... with a bit of luck, you outrun the enemy on the way back as well. Your plane is much lighter after the payload has been dropped
- danielvf 5y agoIt was for bombs, not speed. Here's right from General LeMay's autobiography: "...We had decided to take out the guns and gunners to make up for the shortage of airplanes, because it would be another factor in helping increase the bombload. However, if the change to low altitude had been quite a step to take, then going in at low altitude with half a crew was something else!" The firebombing of Japan was done at low altitude, not high altitude. Do you have a source on heavy bombers over Japan dropping bombs on farmland and fleeing if attacked? That seems against almost every principal of bomber warfare. Lone bombers are much easier to kill than a formation, and an entire formation jettisoning bombs and abandoning their attack just because a few fighters showed up, or AA fire began is hard for me to comprehend.
- asdff 5y ago50+ would have been a small raid. the firebombing of tokyo was like over 300 bombers. Same with those larger raids in europe that destroyed 50% or more of many major cities. WWII was about overwhelming air defenses with a sea of bombers. Japan couldn't do anything about a bomber fleet of that size by like 1943 when US had total air superiority in the pacific and could bomb anything anywhere at that point with their carriers.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe firebombings were done with 4-engine superfortresses, which couldn't be launched from a carrier. These were massive planes that required a proper airbase to deploy. I don't think carriers (or carrier air wings) were involved in the bombing of the Japanese mainland. The famous bombing of Tokyo that you reference was all B-29 superfortresses, launched from a land-base in mariana islands. Superfortresses were so high in altitude, that they couldn't be escorted by typical fighters. Indeed, that was its #1 defense mechanism: just fly higher than other planes (which it could do because of the marvels of pressurized cabins: oxygen masks just weren't good enough to reach that height.) I'm sure the Japanese fighter pilots would fly as high as reasonably possible before shooting their guns at the bombers. -------- There were a few attempts at strategic bombing in 1942 from Chinese bases (ally of the USA at the time). But a single mission used up the entire fuel supply from those bases: it was possible but just not practical. The USA would have to island hop to somewhere closer before attacking the mainland... which began in full capacity in 1944.
- vkou 5y agoThe Doolittle[1] raid was done by carrier-launched bombers (Who then had to land in China and the USSR[2], because they could not land on the carrier that launched them), but that was a one-off propaganda stunt. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doolittle_Raid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doolittle_Raid [2] Because the USSR was not at war with Japan, by the rules of neutrality, the crew got to drink vodka and play cards for the next year, until they 'escaped' Soviet custody into UK/US occupied territories. Their bomber, however, remained.
- vkou 5y ago> Each of those "firebombings" were conducted by 50+ B-29 bombers. When you see so many bombers show up on radar, you dispatch the fighters, you know things are about to happen. 1. By mid-1945, Japan no longer had any fuel for those fighters. 2. B-29s cruised at 40,000', way out of reach of Japanese fighters. At that point in the war, whether or not you see a single, or 50 B-29s, Japanese air defense would ignore them, because Japan no longer had a working air defense. The only difference is that in the latter, the firefighting crews would start getting ready.