4 ms·
It also phones home and reports everything you read, how much, and when. That alone is sufficient reason never to use one.
by sneak 5y ago
It also phones home and reports everything you read, how much, and when.
That alone is sufficient reason never to use one.
- fullstop 5y agoThat's used to synchronize between devices, and you can disable it.
- andrepd 5y agoNo, since it's proprietary software you don't know what it's being used for. But I'd bet a great deal of money in how they store and analyse all that data for purposes of advertising and worse. I personally don't want a list of all the "subversive literature" I read nicely compiled for corporations and government to exploit, fuck that 100x.
- fullstop 5y agoI get it, it's not the device for you. You can leave it disconnected from WiFi and sideload everything if you are that paranoid.
- calcifer 5y agoIt feels like the "Just don't do X if you are that paranoid" attitude is singlehandedly responsible for the increasingly egregious privacy invasions from the last decade.
- fullstop 5y agoI didn't say that. I'm saying that if you don't like how the device operates you can still use it in other ways. If the Kindles forced WiFi to be active and connected to Amazon servers, I'd see your point.
- sneak 5y agoA desire for privacy is not paranoia. You don't even need a threat to desire privacy. It's a human right.
- fullstop 5y agoSurely you see that a desire for privacy is not the same as: > I personally don't want a list of all the "subversive literature" I read nicely compiled for corporations and government to exploit
- sneak 5y agoI do not, that seems like a very basic expression of a desire for privacy. Not wanting your literature choices under surveillance is a common type of privacy that many people, myself included, desire.
- fullstop 5y agoEh, the comment was hyperbolic at best and paranoid at worst. The library knows which books you checked out, and the book store knows which books you've bought. Is this really that much different?
- andrepd 5y agoThe library does not sell my data to thousands of corporations as its core business model. At the book store I can pay cash if I so desire. Yes you're right, it's truly no different from a detailed live-log of everything you read, analysed, packaged, and sold to whomever pays for it.
- andrepd 5y agoWhat don't you like about that sentence? > subversive literature Many books I read were on a list (as in, jail for possession) less than 40 years ago where I live. > nicely compiled for corporations It's literally the explicit purpose of collecting this data. > and government Yes, there's no way a government could ever exploit detailed data about their citizen's behaviour, inclinations, political opinions, etc.
- andrepd 5y agoLol. "Paranoid" is such a loaded word. Not really suited for disliking something which is openly known to happen. Are you "paranoid about catching gonorrhea" if you decide to wear a condom? :-)
- fullstop 5y agoYes. I've been happily married for twenty years, so my perspective is likely to be different. ;-)
- 28605584 5y agoI'm with you. But, as others have noted, there are ways around it, even before there's a jailbreak available: (1) Never connect the device to the Internet. There's really no reason to. (2) Use KFX Output in Calibre, blocking access to the Amazon servers. This is a bit of a hassle but it is doable. Especially since books take hours to read, so you're really only doing the work for a few minutes to get hours of spy-free enjoyment.
- sneak 5y agoWhy buy a Kindle at that point? I have a Likebook Mars that has an SD card slot that I use to load books on to it, which I have never connected to the internet.
- fullstop 5y agoOut of curiosity, do you have ghosting problems with the Mars? You can also connect a kindle to USB and use the internal flash without ever connecting it to the internet.
- sneak 5y agoNo more than any other eink? I haven't noticed anything in particular, but I haven't been looking for ghosting. It works great for my purposes.
- Ekaros 5y agoIt's reasonably priced pretty decent eink reader.
- 28605584 5y agoIn general, I find that Kindle has the best backlight, is fastest, and has a generally very smooth UI. Now, I haven't used the latest version of the OS, so that might have changed, but in general all the non-Kindle E-Ink devices I've used, I've wished it were a Kindle without the spy stuff.
- sillystuff 5y agoI'm hoping the pine note will become a viable device after it releases. A fully open, respects the user, 10" e-ink reader that runs GNU/Linux from an organization that has a proven track record of upstreaming all hardware specific patches to the mainline linux kernel. I expect Debian/Mobian will be available for it, and if battery life isn't terrible, it will be my ideal e-reader. https://www.pine64.org/pinenote/ https://www.pine64.org/pinenote/ https://www.pine64.org/2021/08/15/introducing-the-pinenote/ https://www.pine64.org/2021/08/15/introducing-the-pinenote/ I purchased the original B&N Nook (e-ink) and later one with the front-lit screen. The low price and ability to side-load epubs were the deciding factors, along with there being no freedom respecting alternative. But, later discovered that Nook too phones home with all your reading habits including side loaded content. I rooted both of them (the Nook runs Android), and installed a firewall to block all comm with B&N, and just side-load everything. Acceptable hardware, but the software on the newer models is a dumpster fire (crashes unless you restart device after every few hundred pages read, loses track of what page you were on, have to navigate more screens to do most common tasks, terrible to navigate to book if more than a few loaded onto the device, etc.)-- the original version's software was better in all respects, but still lacking for managing more than a few titles loaded onto the device at once. (edited to make links clickable)
- Jiro 5y ago>Where is the microSD card slot? The case design of the PineNote is fixed, making physical changes like adding a microSD card slot would raise the cost unreasonably. However, revisions of the PineNote motherboard after 1.1 will feature an internal ribbon cable connector where a microSD card slot may be attached. Attaching such a device will require taking the PineNote apart. This attitude by the designers shows fundamental cluelessness.
- sillystuff 5y agoPine64 is a different model than your typical commercial operation. They are trying to get freedom respecting devices into the hands of hackers at the lowest price point possible. They even subsidized device costs for a run of their laptops after lcd panel prices increased. But, usually, they just suspend production until component prices improve. They just began offering a more commercial (supported) experience on some devices if you pay a little more. But, historically, if you purchased a Pine64 device there was no expectation of support beyond a 15 day hardware warranty. They also want to emphasize the difference between the part of the org that sells stuff, and the main org. All commerce takes place on pine64.com. Everything else (forums, wiki, etc.) is on pine64.org. Basically freedom loving hobbyists building stuff and getting it into the hands of other freedom loving hobbyists. And, if it weren't for that second part, none of their devices would be usable. They rely on the community to develop the software for their devices. Not for everyone. But, a worthwhile trade off for some of us.