3 ms·
But much like local services, IP needs government services to function -- it's the customs service that stop cheap knockoff imports, it's the legal system that
by beagle3 15y ago
But much like local services, IP needs government services to function -- it's the customs service that stop cheap knockoff imports, it's the legal system that makes others stop using your patent or levy the rent you as a patent/copyright owner seek. (And eventually, it's the police force and prison system that underwrites the legal system's power).
So it's really no different than other "taxes for services" arrangements.
- corin_ 15y agoI wasn't getting into the question of whether IP should be taxed, merely replying to this statement: If they insist that its intellectual "property", then they'd best start treating it like property. So regardless of whether IP should be taxed, the argument for taxing it is not that all property is taxed - because it isn't.
- beagle3 15y ago> regardless of whether IP should be taxed, the argument for taxing it is not that all property is taxed - because it isn't. That's true. But hard-to-hide expensive stuff (houses, cars, land) IS taxed because it is hard-to-hide and expensive, and patents could equally well have the same fate.