4 ms·
As much as I'm a fan of gratuitous Microsoft bashing, this would be a far better essay without the distracting and counterfactual swipes. Yes, AD does implemen
by dredmorbius 5y ago
As much as I'm a fan of gratuitous Microsoft bashing, this would be a far better essay without the distracting and counterfactual swipes.
Yes, AD does implement a number of previously recommended password management practices, and site administrators can choose to impose these.
No, Microsoft did not come up with those policies.
As I replied to Kyle on Mastodon, my copy of the late Evi Nemeth's UNIX System Administration Handbook 2nd ed, (1995) has a discussion of password aging (automated timed-out passwords) on pages 95 & 544. She's not a fan, but the capabilitiy exists and is noted on Solaris, Irix, and BSDI. She does recommend rotating the root password regularly.
https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/106965632066772456 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/106965632066772456 (thread)
Note that at the time, Microsoft produced largely only single-user operating systems, without any user password at all. (Yes, Windows NT 3.1 was released in 1993. It saw very little use. Active Directory wasn't released until 1999.)
What AD ended up impelemnting was in fact considered best practices at the time. And implementing best practices as standard (and default) configurations is a powerful tool for compliance. As has been demonstrated many times, and curren global events show again, leaving choice to end-users tends to result in very poor safety pratices with severe consequences for all. Unforunatly, knowledge evolves, whilst encoded practices often don't.
Kyle's principle gripe is that Microsoft (and Apple, Amazon, and Google, at the very least) are all racing down the same road as fast as they can of ensuring that their devices form the core of digital identity management. Yes, I'd argue that that is a significant concern.
But better advocacy without needless distractions would help.