3 ms·
> If a "calorie is a calorie" were true, nobody would pay extra for high test gasoline. The total output of an engine has to come from the stoichiometry of the
by kazinator 5y ago
> If a "calorie is a calorie" were true, nobody would pay extra for high test gasoline.
The total output of an engine has to come from the stoichiometry of the fuel, regardless of its anti-knock properties. The total output is the work obtained plus heat, plus whatever energy remains in any incomplete combustion products that are exhausted. Inefficiency caused by knocking means we get less work, but that has to be accompanied by more heat. If we are only measuring heat, or only work, we are doing it wrong. One way is to simply reduce one to the other: make the engine do some work against friction which wastes all of it as heat, and put that whole thing in a closed system (the calorimeter). It cannot be that you get more or less heat out of it if you burn the same amount of gasoline, and obtain the same exhaust products.
The conservation of energy principle is inviolable. If we capture and measure all of the inputs and outputs of an organism (heat, work and solid/liquid/gaseous matter), then any discrepancy between the energy content of two means it is losing energy from its energy stores, or else accumulating it.
The main fallacies in fat control are not violations of thermodynamic principles per se but rather these:
(1) it's easy to simultaneously control the work/heat output and/or the input to obtain an arbitrary desired caloric deficit.
(2) a caloric deficit will always be covered by releasing and burning fat in preference to anything else.