4 ms·
If those devices require LE and still haven't received (automatic) updates already, I'd consider them IoT trash regardless. It's probably part of some IoT botne
by jeroenhd 5y ago
If those devices require LE and still haven't received (automatic) updates already, I'd consider them IoT trash regardless. It's probably part of some IoT botnet already.
Embedded devices that aren't updated regularly for long periods of time are the reason we can't have nice things on the internet.
- DelightOne 5y agoI imagine Botnets may even have an interest in updating the devices themselves..
- adrianN 5y agoThe Invisible Hand keeping your IoT devices chugging along... interesting thought!
- sysadmindotfail 5y agoIt's not hard to imagine someone patching firmware out of sheer annoyance/efficiency. In fact, I bet someone can provide examples of product improvement along the journey of nefarious takeover.
- jeroenhd 5y agoBotnets definitely tend to patch or secure devices they've taken over. Plenty of them kill the ssh or telnet daemon after getting access, and some even patch known vulnerabilities in the web interface. It's a weird battle for control over someone else's hardware.
- nobody9999 5y ago>Embedded devices that aren't updated regularly for long periods of time are the reason we can't have nice things on the internet. No. Embedded devices should generally not be on the Internet at all. Rather, they should have local management/update points and zero access to the Internet. We still wouldn't be able to have nice things on the Internet, due to all the general purpose devices that have been compromised, but there's no reason a light bulb, a refrigerator, a TV or (especially) a camera or microphone should have any contact with the external world. But that breaks the "we're going to display ads on stuff you paid for, and if we spy on you, we can charge more for those ads" business model, and as such, I won't hold my breath and will continue to aggressively manage my DNS and network egress rules.
- quaintdev 5y ago> No. Embedded devices should generally not be on the Internet at all. Rather, they should have local management/update points and zero access to the Internet. This! So much this. There should exist a gateway between these devices and Internet. IoT devices should not have to send data across the Interent in the first place unless user wants to access his home remotely.
- White_Wolf 5y agoI would consider IOT trash any IOT device that demands/requires an internet connection to be functional. The same would apply to any smartphone that requires a sim on first start (or after factory reset). Embedded devices should not even be alowed online. Automatic updates I have mixed feelings about because they (sometimes) have a bad habit of breaking things and give me a ton of hassle.
- xvector 5y agoThread is the future of IoT. Finally a local mesh network that works.
- Avamander 5y agoNot with that idiotic name. The authors deserve a strong paddling.
- jeroenhd 5y agoHonestly, if the internet isn't required for the device to function, I think it shouldn't even be IoT in the first place. I think automatic updates should be part of the device's default lifecycle because nobody will download a ZIP and stick it onto a flash drive to update their fridge. If an automatic update bricks a device, it should be exchanged for free by either the point of sale or the manufacturer because it broke during normal operation. IoT vendors have been given far too much leeway and it's time they're held responsible for the crap they put on the internet.
- White_Wolf 5y agoYou can have IoT devices with LAN only. IoT doesn't mean that it needs to understand DNS and access WAN. For that you can have IoT gateways with proper security in place. The problem with "part of the device lifecycle" is planned obsolescence. I would be up for it though if manufacturers are forced to release the source code and all service information they have the same day they drop support/updates for a product. Edit: I don't think you realise how many applications of lot of "IoT" things have where they are only on a LAN with 0 internet access. Internet access should be optional, not mandatory.