4 ms·
This was a really weird article that reminded me of circa 1999 Slashdot. It’s easy to throw heat at Microsoft. But… 2021 crypto and security is different than
by Spooky23 5y ago
This was a really weird article that reminded me of circa 1999 Slashdot.
It’s easy to throw heat at Microsoft. But… 2021 crypto and security is different than 1991. The standards this stuff was built around were for an era where local dictionary attacks were common and a serious threat. They still are in many scenarios.
If you’re going to throw shit at Microsoft, attack their head in the sand approach to NTLM, their implicit deprecation and failure to develop AD further and prioritization of monetization over baseline product needs.
- mc32 5y agoIf my understanding is right to this day on prem AD does not salt its passwords and MS is not doing anything to address that weakness. That should make everyone tear out their on prem AD.
- Spooky23 5y agoAD exists as it does today because they were able to meet the USGs definition of a distinct crypto module in the 90s, and it’s too popular to break by policy.
- lukeh 5y agoAES keys are salted. Moreover, if you use public key authentication (e.g. smartcard, FIDO) it's not a requirement that any keys are provisioned on the user. I'm not sure if you can disable the generation of the NTLM key when using passwords, though (and it's true, that is unsalted).
- initplus 5y agoActive directory is on the back-burner because it just doesn't have the same growth potential as other products. Everyone who wants to use AD is already using it, and the market size is limited by the number of employees at businesses. If a business grows their customer base by 100x, they don't grow headcount at the same rate. But their resource consumption of cloud managed services will increase more proportionally to the customer base.
- Spooky23 5y agoIf you sell a customer an application, say AD and ADFS, and hobble it so that you sell them the same services again (Azure P2), that is indeed very profitable. Most of the employee costs are CALs, so they are increasing the price significantly if you need security mechanisms that AD cannot provide. The products for customer use are different and don’t really align with the AD bread and butter story, which has always been employees.