3 ms·
> You can do very well believing "a calorie is a calorie" even if it is technically inaccurate I used to think that, but now I'm not so sure. In 2017 I spent
by kelnos 5y ago
> You can do very well believing "a calorie is a calorie" even if it is technically inaccurate
I used to think that, but now I'm not so sure.
In 2017 I spent a lot of effort counting calories (using an app to help keep track). To hit my target (losing a half pound per week), I mostly ate smaller portions and occasionally skipped meals; I didn't really change what I ate, just the amount of it. I rarely hit my target of 0.5lbs per week (often it was half that), losing barely 10lbs over 6 months. (Unfortunately, I gained all of it back in 2018.)
In 2020, once the pandemic hit and restaurants closed, my gf and I started cooking a lot more often than we had previously. So the meals were very different from the restaurant meals we'd usually eat. Our usual meals would be some sort of protein (chicken, steak, pork, lamb), with a vegetable side (usually something potato-based or pasta, though often greens as well). We also started intermittent fasting, and would only eat between roughly noon and 6pm. I lost 15lbs in 4 months (a little over a pound per week, on average).
Exercise-wise it was counter-intuitive as well. In 2017 I was running quite a bit, perhaps 8-10 miles per week. In 2020 my running buddy and I weren't meeting up (pandemic) for a while, so I was hardly running at all, maybe averaging just 2-4 miles per week.
Yet somehow my weight loss in 2020 was much faster and easier than in 2017. The main differences were drastic diet changes and intermittent fasting (and, paradoxically, exercising less). This year I've gained back around 8-10lbs of the 15lbs I lost last year. I'm still (mostly) doing the intermittent fasting, but we're going out to restaurants again, and we've been cooking less often, and sometimes even getting takeout/delivery at home when we're lazy, something we weren't doing all that often during the most isolated parts of the pandemic.
This is of course just my anecdotal experience, and there are a few variables that changed (the intermittent fasting may have played a larger role than I expected), so I certainly can't point to just the one thing here (changing macronutrient consumption vs. just eating less). But this is also making me realize that this is just a complicated topic, and while "weight gain/loss = calories in - calories out" might be a good starting point, I don't think it's sufficient to build a weight loss plan on.
Regardless of the weight loss plan, the most important thing is coming up with a diet that you're happy with and can stick to after you've hit your weight goals. While I haven't gained all the weight back that I lost during the pandemic, I do feel heavier than I'd like to be, and I find it very demotivating that it was so easy to erase much of the progress I made last year.