Not nearly as directly though. Social security is basically money in -> money back. A glorified forced 401k, or at worse a kind of retirement insurance. It's a

Not nearly as directly though. Social security is basically money in -> money back. A glorified forced 401k, or at worse a kind of retirement insurance. It's a bit more separated. When I pay taxes, I don't get a direct return for it, I get (in theory) a fully functioning society. Social security would be a little closer to a sewer and water bill from the city (which you have to pay if you're a owner, but you get a sewer in exchange. Whether you like it or not). It's still not a great analogy because Social security is more deferred. It's really its own thing. Still, it doesn't work quite like a tax either. I personally wouldn't mind if it did though. It's one of those things where we'll pay for it one way or another. If there's an entire generation of people who can't properly retire and pay medical bill, we will pay for them through taxes anyway. May as well do it preemptively and efficiently.