3 ms·
Segueing from “rich” to “multi-billionaires” is a neat trick by rich professionals to divert attention from themselves. Five years ago, we moved into a 3,000 s
by rayiner 5y ago
Segueing from “rich” to “multi-billionaires” is a neat trick by rich professionals to divert attention from themselves.
Five years ago, we moved into a 3,000 square foot house in the Annapolis suburbs. We are right on the water so it cost a princely $485,000. But it was easy to get a house in the neighborhood for $300,000 or so, or just 4 times the county’s median income. As a result, the neighborhood has lots of young families (many without college degrees!), retirees, etc. Today, the house next door is under contract for double the price, and is smaller than ours. As far as I can tell, there’s no billionaires or even centi-millionaires anywhere near us. Just upper middle class people whose 401ks have done really well thanks to the Fed printing money like crazy, not to mention upper middle class welfare like more than a year of deferred student loan payments. (Lower income folks with student loans were already eligible for income based repayment.)
Reaganism has won so completely in America that even AOC doesn’t want to tax upper middle class people. But these are the people directly competing with the middle class for fixed resources. They’re the people driving residents out of gentrifying neighborhoods, driving up the price of coffee, etc. There’s not enough 0.01%-ers out there to move the needle on these assets and services.
- mywittyname 5y agoWell, and most people have fucked up views on what defines "upper middle class". There was a topic on reddit the other night where the most popular posts were saying, without jest, that upper middle class starts at $10 million bucks in liquid savings (and ends around $50MM). That seems to be a typical view on income and wealth in this country: people's opinions are wealth are out or proportion with reality by factors of like 100. For reference, upper middle class technically starts at around $120k/yr, so $10MM could pay 80 years of an upper middle class income. So there's no conceivable way an actual upper middle class family could actually save enough to be consider what the public thinks of as upper middle class.
- shadilay 5y agoI think a bigger factor is that wealth is almost entirely defined by where you live. 120k/yr would be a lot in Iowa but not so much in SF.
- antognini 5y agoIndeed, in San Francisco the low income threshold for a family of four is $117,400 / yr. [1] [1]: https://sfgov.org/scorecards/safety-net/poverty-san-francisco https://sfgov.org/scorecards/safety-net/poverty-san-francisc...
- gamegoblin 5y agoIn my mental model, I’ve always considered upper middle class to be people who still do their own grocery shopping, but don’t really look too closely at the prices. In my experience the kind of people this heuristic selects for is around the same monetary threshold you’ve noted in the low 6 figures.
- rayiner 5y agoYes! My wife and my families both crossed that boundary (on opposite sides of the country) around when we were in high school and we both remember grocery shopping as a key difference.
- jiggawatts 5y agoFor comparison: Sydney has a median house price of AUD $1.4M right now, and a house on the water is $2M-$6M easily. Median income is $56K for Australians in general, and about $90-$110K for areas of Sydney that have water views. Recently the federal deputy treasurer made a speech that younger residents of the city should consider moving to the country to afford a home. The not so minor issue with this statement was that you have to go very far down the list of towns by size in the state to get to a place where he himself could afford a home on his government salary of well over $200K a year!