5 ms·
Increasing supply can help some. But when you do that, you increase demand for material and labor, which can negate some of the benefit depending on what market
by giantg2 5y ago
Increasing supply can help some. But when you do that, you increase demand for material and labor, which can negate some of the benefit depending on what markets we're looking at.
The real problem isn't supply at all, it's the distribution of supply and the choices of people to live there.
- ashtonkem 5y ago> The real problem isn't supply at all, it's the distribution of supply and the choices of people to live there. I’ve said this plenty of times; America has plenty of homes, it just doesn’t have enough homes where people actually want to live. You can get a home in my parents home town (which they left) for $60-100k right now. The issue is that there are no jobs and even fewer services. It was probably a great place to live 80 years ago when small towns were the norm, but now it’s shrinking, aging, and a long distance from any of the amenities that most Americans now demand.
- km3r 5y agoThe same problem of the house price to income ratio shows there is as much of a housing shortage in rural America as well. "Solving" housing by moving all high CoL people to rural America is just going to price out all those with lower CoL area salaries. Our vacancy rate nation wide is low, likely well within the frictional margins that need to exist for a healthy market.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThis is certainly happening in small cities right now, as prices skyrocket.
- giantg2 5y ago"The same problem of the house price to income ratio shows there is as much of a housing shortage in rural America as well." Not necessarily. You can't use the overall picture data to make claims about localized or subcategories of data. Especially if the bulk of the people live in suburban and urban areas.
- giantg2 5y agoRemote work could solve a lot of this. I would love to live in a more rural area with cheaper housing. "... a long distance from any of the amenities that most Americans now demand." Like what? Many amenities and services have been moving to the at-home or online model for decades - arcades, movies, shopping, car buying, telehealth, etc. It seems there should be less reliance on physical amenities now than in the past. We are starting to movement from HCOL and high tax areas. Companies are moving for tax and regulatory purposes and most people seem happy to follow when the cost of living is significantly lower.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThe data seems to imply that remote work is letting high paid workers move from the coasts to smaller cities, not rural towns. The persistent low prices of houses in rural America certainly backs this up. Meanwhile home prices in small cities are skyrocketing. > Like what? Many amenities and services have been moving to the at-home or online model for decades - arcades, movies, shopping, car buying, telehealth, etc. It seems there should be less reliance on physical amenities now than in the past. My parents town’s nearest major store is a Walmart 45 minutes away. There is a significant difference between “we need less amenities now” and “we need no amenities”. Committing to an hour and a half drive for anything Amazon can’t deliver is sub ideal.
- 0xffff2 5y agoThe price of houses in rural America seems to also be skyrocketing. My house 40 miles outside of the nearest "smaller city" (population ~20k) has gone up in value over 50% since I bought it 3 years ago.
- harambae 5y agoThe price of land in the middle of the desert east of San Diego (Ocotillo Wells, Borrego Springs) is skyrocketing. It would be utterly impractical to live there most of the year. And yet compared to NFT's and some cryptocurrencies it's probably a great investment. There's definitely a bubble going on, I just don't know when it will end or why.
- km3r 5y agoNo, vacancy rates are at near all time lows. Any reputable study will show we have a housing shortage. Even in rural America, house prices are skyrocketing. We need to build more, ideally near transit hubs as to minimize the effect on infrastructure, and reduce our environmental impact.
- giantg2 5y agoTons of empty houses in the Appalachian region. The vacancy rate may be at a low, but it is still about 10%. Sure, we still need to build more houses, but the point here is that distribution is important to both. If you build houses in a HCOL area, the cost will be higher. We should be looking at redistributing to areas with the highest rates of vacancy an LCOL. Part of why prices are going up is inflation and cost of materials and labor. Prices in rural america are up, but I wouldn't say skyrocketing. There might be places that are skyrocketing, but I'm guessing they are in commute distance of the cities.
- resonantjacket5 5y agoThose aren't really useful homes then. The housing crisis is more accurately an imbalance of houses-to-jobs in a metro area.
- giantg2 5y agoRemote work can unbound that, at least within a low percentage situation, like under 10% vacant. Not to mention that some companies are moving out of higher cost areas to lower cost ones (like CA to TX).
- resonantjacket5 5y agoLol, and once you build houses in those new regions, I'd assume those neighbors also block new housing from being built near them? Plus there's still plenty of jobs that cannot be done remotely, I feel generally in the tech world people are highly overestimating the amount of remote jobs proportional to the rest of the population. Why the companies are moving from California to Texas is exactly because Texas' local zoning laws aren't as stringent allowing for cheaper housing. The fix really isn't that complicated, it's allow more houses to be built where jobs are demanded. Not quite sure why people always twist and turn justifications for why only 1-story houses should be built.