3 ms·
I'm still not sure how I feel about the F.U.. There is something incredibly leap-out-of-a-cathedral-window-and-fall-to-the-ground-hitting-a-power-chord about it
by KirinDave 18y ago
I'm still not sure how I feel about the F.U.. There is something incredibly leap-out-of-a-cathedral-window-and-fall-to-the-ground-hitting-a-power-chord about it, but at the same time it seems incredibly judgmental and hopelessly hostile to newbies.
There's definitely something to the idea though. I remember the last CodeCon I attended with great fondness, and CodeCon is to some degree and exemplification of the F.U. ideals without the hostility.
- gruseom 18y agoleap-out-of-a-cathedral-window-and-fall-to-the-ground-hitting-a-power-chord Did you just make that up? I like it!
- KirinDave 18y agoYeah. It's like saying "Je ne sais quoi" and then hanging truck nuts off of it. ;) Or shouting "YOU ESS A!" during a wedding. Something indescribably asinine and unmistakably western but still awesome and laudable at the same time.
- orib 18y agoI don't see it as being especially unfriendly to newbies. Perhaps a bit nerve-wracking, but "Bring something cool to show on your first meeting. And make sure it's actually cool. We'll ask lots of questions" seems like it may actually be fun. And IMO, it would definitely help keep a good atmosphere with interesting hacks alive. You'd need to be careful to prevent people from being assholes to the noobs, and prevent things from degenerating into hazing. However, if it's done right with care to keep things polite, this could be a demanding, challenging, and therefore fun experience. Anyone interested in starting one up in the Greater Toronto Area? =P Edit: Clarify things a bit
- tel 18y agoThe hostility is undoubtedly Zed's calling card, but I feel a great deal of affinity for it. Trial by fire keeps a well defined line between FU and everyone else. Selective permeability is how you maintain a gradient.
- KirinDave 18y agoBut at the same time, most hackers are introverts. Even today people are incredibly reluctant to show code before it is "done" for fear of rejection. It's going to be very difficult for the shy kid who may be a great coder but is bad with rejection to walk into that gauntlet knowing full well that people will give them a rough time. It's only a kind of renaissance of sharing exemplified by sites like github that are showing a return to the enthusiastic sharing of early hackerdom.
- davidw 18y ago> But at the same time, most hackers are introverts. This cuts both ways though... will most hackers really be able to muster up the will to tell someone to go away? I know I wouldn't really like doing that. While I have no doubt that Zed - or at least his internet persona - could, I wonder how it'll work out in practice.
- tel 18y agoIsn't that the point? It's not for everyone, sure, but if you can just jump in and combat introversion all at once then more power to you and welcome to the FU.
- khafra 18y agoI would attend one if it had a whelk's chance in a supernova of spreading to Tampa Bay. 1) People aren't as tactless and rejection-happy in real life as they are on the internet. 2) If it survives past two meetings, it'll be because the respected elders have cultivated an environment of constructive criticism, focused on the hack. Relentless haranguing of the hacker doing the presenting will be reserved for the marketing flacks that try to sneak in.
- dhotson 18y agoYeah, I'm a bit the same. I was really enthusiastic about it at first. But after following a bit of the discussion on the mailing lists and IRC, I'm a little put off with a few things. A lot of the discussion seems to be focussed on excluding people, this just strikes me as elitist. The idea is good. I really love the idea that people are required to show something. I often fall into the trap being interested in stuff, but not actually creating new stuff. Forcing people to create stuff is a really good way to keep the focus on the creativity side of things.