3 ms·
iCloud photos are not E2E encrypted. Apple has announced no plans whatsoever to make them such. Apple, their sysadmins, and the government can see every photo
by sneak 5y ago
iCloud photos are not E2E encrypted. Apple has announced no plans whatsoever to make them such. Apple, their sysadmins, and the government can see every photo you have in iCloud.
Apple had plans (and, an inside source tells me, an implementation) to do E2E for iCloud Backup, but the FBI asked them not to, so they scrapped it:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusive/exclusive-apple-dropped-plan-for-encrypting-backups-after-fbi-complained-sources-idUSKBN1ZK1CT https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...
This undermines the credibility of those who are claiming, without evidence, that this clientside CSAM scanning is a prelude to launching E2E for iCloud data.
- philwelch 5y agoOkay, so basically they are just sort of pinky-swearing that your iCloud photos are encrypted on iCloud, but not in any way that prevents Apple or the government from decrypting them anyway. This raises the followup question of "why bother scanning the images on-device?", but I can infer two fairly obvious answers. First, the encryption still keeps AWS/Azure/GCP from seeing my photos. Second, and more cynically, they'd have to pay to do computation in the cloud; on-device computation is free to them. > This undermines the credibility of those who are claiming, without evidence, that this clientside CSAM scanning is a prelude to launching E2E for iCloud data. I agree; this is consistent with my initial point of confusion. Thanks!
- GeekyBear 5y ago> Okay, so basically they are just sort of pinky-swearing that your iCloud photos are encrypted on iCloud, but not in any way that prevents Apple or the government from decrypting them anyway. How do you imagine that Google and Microsoft are able to scan the entire contents of your account? They can all read the data on their servers >This raises the followup question of "why bother scanning the images on-device? Because running the scan on device and encrypting the results protects users from having their account associated with the inevitable false positives that are going to crop up. Apple can't decrypt the scan results your device produces until the threshold of 30 matching images is reached. If someone issues a warrant to Apple for every account that has a single match, they can honestly report that they don't have that information. Google and Microsoft give you no such protection. Any data held on their server is wide open for misuse by anyone who can issue a warrant.
- philwelch 5y agoI’m not arguing with anyone or expressing any opinion.
- WorldMaker 5y agoIf their end goal is to go full E2E encryption for iCloud Backup, but they have to be able to prove to the FBI first that they are doing "due diligence" to meet warrant needs then of course device-side CSAM scanning is a prelude for being able to turn on E2E for iCloud data! The fact that the FBI stopped them once before and they've been working to build active solutions to what the FBI tells them their needs are should be evidence alone that E2E is their goal. It seems pretty credible to me.