3 ms·
I think it depends on the actual threat model. It's a bit weird that HTTPS-everywhere was initiated in the aftermath of the Snowden leaks. If your enemy is the
by xg15 5y ago
I think it depends on the actual threat model.
It's a bit weird that HTTPS-everywhere was initiated in the aftermath of the Snowden leaks. If your enemy is the CIA or NSA etc, HTTPS probably won't help you: They can compromise your CDN or simply go for your hoster directly.
However, there are many smaller and more common threats against HTTPS provides significant defense that wasn't there before. In particular manipulative ISPs or public WiFis or third parties who are logged into the same WiFi as you and are capturing traffic. (Remember Firesheep etc)
That being said, I also believe there are some significant downsides to the HTTPS push (and also DoH, eSNI and friends) that browser vendors refuse to address. In particular:
- It's a huge driver of "platformisation" of the web: To access an increasing amount of browser features, you now have to rely on third party services - at the very least, you need a domain. This is particularly problematic for hobbyist projects, local-only networks and home servers.
- It normalizes a situation where network traffic is treated as a black box. It's a good thing if my ISP or the cafe I'm working in can't inspect my packets - it's highly problematic if my company's admin has no idea what is going on inside the network or if I can't even inspect traffic from my own devices. I'm seriously wondering who is protecting against what here. This seems less for protecting users against snoopers and more for protecting tech companies against their own users - which is really the opposite of privacy.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> - It normalizes a situation where network traffic is treated as a black box. It's a good thing if my ISP or the cafe I'm working in can't inspect my packets - it's highly problematic if my company's admin has no idea what is going on inside the network or if I can't even inspect traffic from my own devices. I'm seriously wondering who is protecting against what here. This seems less for protecting users against snoopers and more for protecting tech companies against their own users - which is really the opposite of privacy. Yeah, this is... troublesome, especially how fond software developers seem to be of telemetry these days. For software you haven't compiled yourself, that's completely opaque data leaving your network. Especially in the light of how incredibly difficult it is to disable that telemetry collection in Firefox, it's not a great look for mozilla. I don't know if this is the authoritative guide du jour, but the steps usually go something like this: https://gist.github.com/gamunu/7fbee4e2318fdc080395a7f74cc34fe9 https://gist.github.com/gamunu/7fbee4e2318fdc080395a7f74cc34... I'm not sure this trust we're effectively being coerced to put in software and platforms is great from a privacy standpoint. But as you said, there has not been a lot of talk about this.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI just keep thinking if the something like the BonziBuddy scandal had been pulled off today, how would anyone ever find out? Well, actually, we have Siri, Alexa, Cortana and Google Assistant now, and the pitch is eerily familiar in many ways.