4 ms·
As a designer myself I know where he is coming from. But it's also obvious that he is building up a strawman. First of all when you do A/B testing you don't as
by ThomPete 15y ago
As a designer myself I know where he is coming from. But it's also obvious that he is building up a strawman.
First of all when you do A/B testing you don't ask the user. You test what composition get the most clicks.
Second A/B does not mean beautiful/ugly but for instance high contrast on call to action / low contrast on call to action.
Third you can't claim that there is no right design and then go on to claim that A/B testing is wrong because it forces you to choose between two alternatives. Then he is basically contradicting his entire claim.
Fourth. There are cases when design is important and cases where it's not. It's not always important and good design is not always beautiful in the way he seem to be talking about it.
At the end of the day better conversion must be the aim for any design. If you want to do art you should become an artist.
Design matters a lot, aesthetics less so. In fact aesthetics are a rather contextually relative thing and should be judged as such.
Only designers who think about A/B as the OP don't like A/B testing. There are plenty who understand that it can actually lead to better design.