3 ms·
> 'corporations are responsible for 95% of carbon emissions' Well, is that factoid wrong though? Sometimes personal responsibility is just a smokescreen pushed
by Apocryphon 5y ago
> 'corporations are responsible for 95% of carbon emissions'
Well, is that factoid wrong though? Sometimes personal responsibility is just a smokescreen pushed by bigger fish to guilt the smaller ones, red herrings. Same situation as the California water shortage where personal use is massively dwarfed by agricultural use of water.
- samhw 5y agoWell, the obvious question is "why do you think those corporations exist, and for what reason are they emitting that carbon?"
- Apocryphon 5y agoWell? Do you have any links, or why even bring up a popular notion only to debunk it offhandedly?
- samhw 5y agoAny links for what?
- Apocryphon 5y agoThe wrongheadedness of 'corporations are responsible for 95% of carbon emissions'
- samhw 5y agoI'm not making a recondite point here. I think maybe you're thinking I'm saying something more complex than I am. My point is that companies exist because they provide goods and services which people want to buy. The S&P 100 aren’t sitting around a carbon campfire, passing a massive carbon joint, while they chat about how much they enjoy destroying the environment.
- Apocryphon 5y agoYour entire point is that the narrative that industrial-scale carbon producers are chiefly responsible for carbon production is itself faulty, because it obviates personal responsibility. Because those businesses are doing it behest of consumers. Is that right? It seems like a false dichotomy, because one can affirm personal responsibility and place the blame on the main culprits of an activity. And to claim that businesses are forced into do that because of consumers- well when do individual consumers get a chance to express their feelings at how carbon is produced by the businesses they patronize? How transparent is the production process to consumers? There is information asymmetry at play. Reducing such a complex issue into a simple moral judgment about personal responsibility (or the dodging thereof) would seem to be an oversimplification.
- samhw 5y ago> Your entire point is that the narrative that industrial-scale carbon producers are chiefly responsible for carbon production is itself faulty, because it obviates personal responsibility. Because those businesses are doing it behest of consumers. Yup, exactly. Calling businesses the 'main culprit' is absurd, like placing the blame on slaughterhouses for people eating meat.
- Apocryphon 5y agoIt looks like a third of carbon production is caused by twenty some oil extracting companies: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/companies-carbon-emissions/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/companies-carbon-emissions/ There’s definitely a place for personal responsibility in terms of land or air travel, but it’s hard to blame individual consumers for things like America’s car culture, the product of decades of urban planning and lack of support for public transit.
- samhw 5y agoWell, this is not much different from other emergent phenomena like election results. The outcome of the 2020 election was not under any one person's control, but that's a shoddy argument for claiming it's outside of everyone's control in aggregate. (I mean, it's certainly not in any company's control either.) The answer is that we need to coordinate, get serious, and fix these problems. But part of getting serious is not using obvious sophistry to trick dull-witted people into thinking that 'corporations' are just magically burning carbon for reasons that have nothing at all to do with their consumption, and therefore there's no point in their changing their own behaviour –– which is a very prevalent argument on social media, and is what I was alluding to initially.