12 ms·
Nano98: Windows 98 that boots and runs under 5MB (2003)
- m1el 5y agoI wish this was possible today. But I won't get a small Windows 10 distribution no matter how hard I try or how much I'm willing to pay.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- exikyut 5y agoYou can, however, get Windows AME, which is kinda interesting. https://ameliorated.info/ https://ameliorated.info/
- m1el 5y agoThanks, this seems like a good source of information!
- rkagerer 5y agoHow long has it been around? Anyone here used it extensively enough to recommend?
- exikyut 5y agoAn excellent question. It seems interesting, and like it has a reasonable social consensus, but I do wonder if everyone'll just be going hunting for LTSB 5-10 years from now. ...Maybe treat it like Existential Arch Linux? (Where "existential" applies to both "the project might be dead in a few years" and "they disable Windows Update, so not actually Arch Linux" :D)
- Tijdreiziger 5y ago> To assure that our changes are permanent, we need to remove Windows Update and its self-healing ability. Yikes...
- janci 5y agoI actually used this to run Windows in a BOSCH emulator on my first smartphone - HTC TyTN II. It was painfully slow and unusable for any practical purposes.
- numlock86 5y agoWhat's a BOSCH emulator? Or is this a "bochs" typo?
- stragies 5y agoHe meant "bochs"; I suspect an "autocorrect" miscorrection, my tablet does also include popular brand names as "helpful" suggestions. And when you don't see any red waves under the words before submitting, that miscorrection might go unnoticed when posting.
- st_goliath 5y ago> BOSCH emulator Do you perhaps mean Bochs[1]? I've seen it booting Windows 95 on an early PSP and similar stunts, so running Windows inside Bochs on a smartphone would IMO not be that much out of the ordinary. Or is there really a PC emulator from BOSCH[2] available somewhere? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bochs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bochs [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bosch_GmbH https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bosch_GmbH
- hyproxia 5y agoIt's obvious that he meant Bochs, no need to play dumb.
- st_goliath 5y agoAt least over here (Germany & Austria) Bosch is a very common household name, as they not only are one of the larger employers around, but also have their logo on lots of common household appliances (e.g. dish washers, washing machines, ...) and tools, in addition to manufacturing ECUs for pretty much the entire German car industry. I just found the idea quite funny that I could have a "BOSCH emulator" in my tool box, right next to my BOSCH electric drill. Especially since OP even used the capitalized spelling from the brand logo. I'm not trying to be mean here, I genuinely found it funny and tried to point that out the way people usually do in social interactions, rather than rudely responding along the lines of "OMG you made a typo there". I guess that got a little "lost in translation" due to the textual medium and culture difference?
- snvzz 5y agoSilly it has such complex instructions, instead of a script. Discourages me from even trying this... can't be that good if the person that made it couldn't even make a script.
- vanderZwan 5y agoThis was a website of someone sharing a little passion project with the world. Not someone trying to convince you to do as they did because they are convinced that their way of doing things was the right way.
- nix23 5y agoThat was in 2003 when people could read and stuff more content into their head then one twitter tweet.
- hnlmorg 5y agoThe instructions are hardly complicated and frankly I'm not sure it would be safe to write this in an 98 era batch file. eg removing any files not in a file list is a risky process in itself regardless of the constraints of DOS batch files.
- fraktl 5y agoInstructions are not complex, they're the opposite - they're extremely simple.
- noxer 5y ago2003 was the per-spoonfeeding era.
- rvba 5y agoI used to do this to have more space on my old machine. Sadly I deleted my first drawings made in Windows Paint
- pcardoso 5y agoI had a friend that did this to run Windows 3.0 (IIRC) on his old 286 from a single floppy.
- cjdell 5y agoLove this. Now someone show me how to make a nano Windows 10 installation without all the telemetry BS. Essentially the kernel only with custom explorer.exe. Experimented with modding Hyper-V Server (the free one) with some success, but too many DLLs missing and multimedia functions don't work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- merlinscholz 5y agoIt is still Windows 10, but Windows LTSC would be a start. Works fine for daily use after you restore some small things.
- exikyut 5y agoWindows AME (https://ameliorated.info/ https://ameliorated.info/) is a bit extreme, but technically does do this
- cjdell 5y agoI've searched high and low for something like this. Will give this a try. Thanks
- IntelMiner 5y agoHoly shit they remove Windows Update? That sounds like a great way to slide into madness as software breaks or malware rears its head
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoEh, honestly I usually have Windows Update disabled anyway because it causes much more headache than it is worth. Occasionally, once a year at most, I re-enable and update and it has about a 50/50 chance of not making me wish I'd just reinstalled instead.
- 5y ago
- fdfsasd22323 5y agoThis is a pretty cool find! I feel inclined to share my project from a while ago, where the idea was (inspired by Dockerfiles) to automate the building of a working Windows 98 installation in QEMU. It's fairly janky and slow, but it does what it promises and starting from usual installation media will produce a HDD image with Windows 98 installed and somewhat customised (containing some files I wanted and a custom desktop wallpaper and such). https://github.com/visual2000/paschke https://github.com/visual2000/paschke EDIT: Looking closer, it would be possible to steal tips from this guide to make it quicker and faster probably - although the aim with Paschke was to start from a vanilla installation media, instead of just putting the minimum files needed into a disk image.
- azalemeth 5y agoIn the days when Windows was easier to crack, it was not uncommon to find very small, specialised ISOs of "miniature windows" designed specifically for running a certain task -- typically some form of data-recovery app, system repair/maintenance or similar -- and they would fit on a single CD-R, have almost no system requirements, and, if I recall successfully, be bloody useful to my school's computer administrators who otherwise just had to reimage machines all the time with Norton Ghost. Nowadays it seems that a Windows ISO does not come up short of 4 GB and this tradition of "repacking" them into small, optimised, crap-free operating systems (albeit of questionable legality, but inevitably used on a machine that had a real windows license!) has been lost. I lament this.
- ntauthority 5y agoWith Windows being componentized, this is often a lot easier than it used to be - there's official minimal editions like the forgotten Nano Server (or an attempt at remaking it like remin-core: https://github.com/replisys/remin-core https://github.com/replisys/remin-core), IoT, Factory OS and whatnot, but even adding the legacy GUI subsystem you can get somewhat small when building Windows PE variants like used for the default setup/recovery images. At least a few years ago some of this trend was still alive making little PE images that could almost be used for real desktop use on sites like reboot.pro and other spin-offs, though it seems to be a lot less mainstream than the piracy heydays during the XP era.
- easton 5y agoFactory OS is pretty interesting because it can run any Win32 app (outside of a hypervisor) via a container, something you couldn’t do with WinPE as often there were too many libraries missing to get something like Chrome running. I wonder if they’ll ever use it to replace WinPE. They’ve had the same installer since Vista, and it probably needs a redo (it still takes forever to install Windows).
- zeusk 5y agoIt's still possible to customize .wim images and have post-install scripts to declutter stuff but straying from standardized edition components can cause future updates to lead to a corrupted state, which was the case with windows xp as well. It's just not a large enough use case to warrant support. For repair/maintenance, there is WinPE (and now, live USB boot)
- pacifika 5y agoThe size of a typically large webpage.
- cies 5y ago> I have only tested this with Windows 98se. Win98SE the last windows i actually enjoyed using and believed it was an improvement over the its predecessor. Nowadays im afraid to run modern windows without a VM and a firewall.
- xav_authentique 5y agoNo love for Windows 2000? NT kernel with the classic Windows interface. It ran pretty well on Windows 98 machines and was extremely stable.
- dleslie 5y agoSo long as you didn't play games. 2000 meant abandoning the vast majority of your PC game library, early on.
- com2kid 5y agoYou could hack around that and get DirectX working, I was doing all my gaming on Windows 2000 back in the day. Though I think I may have had a proper dos boot disk for some games, hard to remember, it was quite awhile back. :)
- dleslie 5y agoYou would've needed a DOS boot disk, yes; while Win98SE was fairly great for playing DOS games, 2000 was most certainly not.
- babypuncher 5y agoI ran Windows 2000 in high school and never had trouble running any of my games. That said, I didn't have any DOS games in my library, which I'm guessing is what you are referring to.
- garaetjjte 5y ago>It ran pretty well on Windows 98 machines I don't think so, for example requirements for RAM: Windows 98: 16 megabytes (MB) of memory (24 MB recommended) Windows 2000: 64 megabytes (MB) of RAM recommended minimum;
- desktopninja 5y agoMy goto to tool to get WindowsXP down to ~100MB (drivers mostly): https://www.nliteos.com/ https://www.nliteos.com/
- Teknoman117 5y agoI had that mixed up with ntlite in my head (which will do windows 10). I used this to make a custom Win 10 install for my first gen threadripper desktop. There were major teething issues since I bought it on launch day. Specifically, the Intel wifi driver that was bundled in the windows installer at that point would blue-screen on threadripper the moment it loaded. Intel had an updated driver available, but the bad driver was literally in the windows installer. I couldn't actually get to first boot. Used ntlite to make a custom windows installer where the only change was the updated intel wifi driver.
- Maakuth 5y agoThis could be a nice OS for archive.org's browser embedded PC emulator environment: https://archive.org/details/win95_in_dosbox https://archive.org/details/win95_in_dosbox . Not so fun to download 45 megabytes of Windows installation to try out some piece of shareware :)
- telendram 5y agoI think the pb is that it's so barebone that pretty much nothing works out of the box. One has to add a few more components, depending on which application needs to run (as an OS alone is, well, not an end in itself). However, that's where it stings : adding "components", yet but which ones ? in which order ? how ? Componentization was not a topic, so there's no tool, almost no doc, just tribal knowledge on the topic. That makes it essentially useless for the vast majority of humanity.
- Maakuth 5y agoThat does make sense. I suppose one could gather a record by hooking the kernel to log which files were accessed and which were not. But that would be a lot of trouble and the end result would just kill the cacheability of the base OS layer of those emulation images.
- marcodiego 5y agoI remember how live distributions became popular among technicians in early 2000's. The main advantages they had over windows were could more easily pack lots of software, there was nothing to care about license and popular hardware usually worked out of the box without needing to install specific drivers. If anyone is impressed by these 5MB, please remember this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28515025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28515025
- LeSaucy 5y agoHirens was a brilliant tool for cleaning malware infected systems. Most malware of the time would prevent opening task manager, regedit, services.msc etc. Often business systems of the era had so much manually configured or proprietary software that it wasn’t always possible to wipe and reinstall.
- Teknoman117 5y agoI used to keep a 2.88 MB floppy with tomsrtbt on it.
- tossaway9000 5y agoI've seen webpack builds larger than this... much larger.
- lmilcin 5y agoMy first PC I ever owned was scrap gathered from my friends. My only HDD was 120MB Conner Peripherals HDD that fell on asphalt out of jacket pocket of my friend while he was riding a bike (no kidding!) and was crisscrossed with bad sectors. I put up an ambitious (back then) plan to map out all broken sectors and then try to fit Windows 95 and Delphi2 onto the rest. I remember I was left with something like 70MB of usable disk space and most of it was devoted to Delphi 2. I have spent a number of days iterating moving some Windows files, restarting to see if it still boots and does the job, restoring the files if it did not. I was left with something like 20MB (? I assume, I don't remember exactly). There was not a single file that I could remove without breaking it, I have edited a lot of registry and INI files to disable features to let me remove as much as possible. There was no sound support, no plug&play, no unnecessary tools, nothing. Hats off if you can do the same to Windows98 and shrink it to 5MB. It also reminds me the well known Things That Turbo Pascal Is Smaller Than (https://prog21.dadgum.com/116.html https://prog21.dadgum.com/116.html)
- exikyut 5y agoThis is honestly awesome. You would've learned more about the system by accident/happenstance than most people learn in years. You don't have the HDD anymore by any chance, do you? :) it would be cool to image it... So basically you had 70MB total to work with, you squished Win95 into 50MB, then had 20MB for Delphi? What were the rest of the system's specs, and what era was this in?
- lmilcin 5y agoIt was circa 1998. It was 386DX, 96MB of memory, had monochromatic monitor, no enclosure (it rested on a towel) and no mouse (yes, I programmed graphical UIs without a mouse). Obviously no networking of any kind. Yes, it had more memory than HDD! It was my first development machine (after programmable calculator which was stolen) so I have fond memories of it. I believe minimum Delphi 2 install was over 70MB so I also had to cut it up to fit the drive.
- badsectoracula 5y ago
- wolpoli 5y agoAfter discovering that the Windows 98 DOS bootup disks boots DOS, creates a ram drive, and decompresses the various utilities into a ram drive, I decided that it would be fun optimizing the bootup disk. I tried various things that include switching out the cabinet decompressor with pkunzipjr and formating the floppy disk with 2MGUI, a utility that puts 2 megabytes of data onto a disk, but I couldn't fit the 3 disks set into 1 disk. Those were fun times.
- dang 5y agoThe submitted URL (http://web.archive.org/web/20090209050149/http://www.etek.chalmers.se/~e8gus/nano98/ http://web.archive.org/web/20090209050149/http://www.etek.ch...) is crashing due to an "internal error", so I've changed it to a different URL which isn't - at least for now.
- earksiinni 5y agoHellz yes. I remember buying this and hacking together my own Win 98 distros: https://www.litepc.com/98lite.html https://www.litepc.com/98lite.html Can't believe that their product page is still up. I believe it came about after the 90's MS anti-trust cases. MS argued that IE was integral to Windows, so these devs made a product to strip IE out, just to show that it wasn't as integral as MS claimed. Then they built on it and it became a legit product for slimming down Windows installs.
- donatj 5y agoI misread that "Windows 98 that boots and runs under SMB" and was fully expecting a Windows 98 thin client or something of the sort.
- zandorg 5y agoXP had no modern browser... Until now! http://www.mypal-browser.org 800,000 users can't be wrong (out of 240 million XP users worldwide). This project is important because Firefox stopped working on XP 4 years ago - and you can't do things like captchas without a modern browser.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mintplant 5y agoLooks like the Mypal project is currently imploding due to a license dispute: https://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/3 https://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/3
- lostgame 5y agoDid anyone else here ever use/would recall a Windows XP district called ‘TinyXP’, which would run under some similarly phenomenal specs? I spent years using that; especially in VM’s! In the early days of Intel Macs, I used TinyXP almost exclusively in Parallels. :)