3 ms·
>But the most striking results emerged when participants were asked to generate existential explanations that offered comfort and peace of mind. There's a whol
by coldtea 5y ago
>But the most striking results emerged when participants were asked to generate existential explanations that offered comfort and peace of mind.
There's a whole great difference between "generating existential explanations that offered comfort and peace of mind" and actually having "existential explanations that offered comfort and peace of mind".
In the first case, the participants wrote some explanations that they thought should offer comfort and peace of mind (key word: should).
In the second case, those explanations actually offered them comfort and peace of mind.
The first case, explanations that you can up with that oughta offer comfort and peace of mind, are a dime a dozen.
The second case, things that actually offer comfort and peace of mind are orders of magnitude rarer (and historically religion has been found effective in this).
And it's easy to fool one's self (especially given the culture we're in, where it's a faux pass to be religious in "polite company") that, "this god-less scientific explanation should be fine for the purpose of meaning", as if people are logical machines satisfied with mere technical explanation, or as if those explanations arrive at some ultimate meaning, when all they offer are the mechanics of the thing.
I'm not saying the scientific explanations are wrong, and the religious ones are right.
I'm saying that the religious ones (a) are based on faith (so they command, assuming you do believe, a larger part of your inner commitment than mere objective reasoning), and (b) are specifically structured to answer the meaning/why part, not just the how part.
Sure, religious explanations can be innefective, if you don't believe in them.
But scientific explanation can not be as effective as belief, because you don't really believe in them: they're proven and broken down for you (as to how they work), so you don't have to believe in them.
So, it's somewhat like the difference between trusting someone blindly (like a kid does with their parents), and "trusting" someone because they do trustworthy things.
In the latter case, you don't really trust them: you weight what they do (and are always vigilant that they might fail to be worthy of your trust). Both cases involve trust, but one is an inherent belief, and the other is an observation based on past performance.
Never mind which is more correct: which one do you think offers more "comfort and peace of mind"? I'd say blind trust wins hands down - and likewise belief-driven explanations.