3 ms·
If you think that society can function without those jobs being done, then there actually isn't an issue and there isn't a shortage, there's actually a surplus.
by pessimizer 5y ago
If you think that society can function without those jobs being done, then there actually isn't an issue and there isn't a shortage, there's actually a surplus. If you don't think that society can function with a pure workforce of managers, bureaucrats, and specialists, then you believe that no matter the individual merits and judgments you make of people's inherent worth, a large proportion of them will actually have to build, move, or operate physical objects.
These are the people who you're saying are asking for a free lunch. The people who do things, rather than comment on them. If everyone reached the baseline of worthiness that you've set up, you'd just have more educated strawberry pickers (or import more slaves.)
> But the progress in labor fairness in the US, 8 hour work days, minimum wage, workplace safety, has been fought for in literal blood.
The blood of the people you're talking shit about. Not your blood, not your classes' blood. The you 100 years ago was making this same fucking speech about how spoiled workers were for wanting any of that, and that in your day you had actual slaves who understood the value of work.
This is really a slimy take. If we paid people based on their effort rather than our leverage, there wouldn't be a problem. Free lunches are being eaten, but not by the people who quit washing dishes and waiting tables i.e. making and serving your lunch.
- crazydoggers 5y agoYou don’t actually know what you’re talking about since, yes, they were my “class”… indeed my relatives. Society can’t function without these jobs. It’s precisely why the jobs are important, why they aren’t demeaning; why people should take pride and be given respect for doing them. Complaining that working jobs in the sun, or cleaning toilet is beneath you is what I have a problem with, and is what these people are saying. I think we’re on the same side. There are people who think being a janitor is beneath them and they would never do it… unless of course they were paid a CEOs wages for it. And that not hyperbole, that’s the hyper distorted reality I think some people are living in. If you think everyone should be compensated the same, then I don’t think there’s common ground. If you think there needs to be an increase in minimum wage. Better working conditions, then I couldn’t agree more. But those things aren’t accomplished by complaining life is unfair. That unskilled jobs pay less than being a software developer. They’re accomplished by working hard, getting out what you put in, and organizing, voting and working for change. Progressivism is a constant struggle. It doesn’t come for free and that’s life.