4 ms·
In most Autopilot-related incidents, wasn't the driver somehow intentionally defeating safety features, such as by hanging a weight on the steering wheel? IMO,
by josephcsible 5y ago
In most Autopilot-related incidents, wasn't the driver somehow intentionally defeating safety features, such as by hanging a weight on the steering wheel? IMO, if you knowingly and intentionally defeat any safety system, you should be 100% on the hook for anything that happens that the safety system might have prevented, no matter how misleading any messaging may be.
- rastafang 5y ago> In most Autopilot-related incidents, wasn't the driver somehow intentionally defeating safety features, such as by hanging a weight on the steering wheel? It is full-auto-pilot... so it shouldn't be an issue. But either way, I don't think that it was the case in most malfunctions.
- Andys 5y agoBut is it? Tesla insist that you be ready to take over driving at any time
- josephcsible 5y ago> It is full-auto-pilot... so it shouldn't be an issue. That's not how autopilot works even in planes, and Tesla makes it very clear that you need to pay attention before it lets you enable it for the first time.
- rastafang 5y agoSo full-auto-pilot (Tesla) is the same as auto-pilot (planes) and also the same as not-auto-pilot (English)
- theluketaylor 5y agoNo, the issues NTSB was looking into stem from Tesla's terrible stationary object detection. 10+ people using autopilot as directed have plowed into the back of stopped emergency services vehicles.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoNTHSA requested docs on this issue from 12 automakers in total, as all of their emergency braking systems have this limitation when utilizing driver assistance systems. My theory is that it’ll eventually be a requirement to detect emergency vehicles optically using a similar system to how traffic lights detect emergency vehicle strobe lights and give them priority (Opticon system). This is trivial with a front facing camera, but not possible with radar. https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/us-asks-12-automakers-assistance-tesla-probe-2021-09-14/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/us-ask...
- simfree 5y agoIf this is so trivial with front facing camera, why has Tesla not implemented it? Stationary object detection appears to be totally missing, whether it's Tesla repeatedly trying to smash itself into the concrete support posts for the Seattle Monorail, pedestrians at an intersection, emergency vehicles flashing a standardized set of lights, etc
- toomuchtodo 5y agohttps://www.tesla.com/support/transitioning-tesla-vision https://www.tesla.com/support/transitioning-tesla-vision In some cases, they have. My Model Y has no front facing radar, but supports automatic emergency braking with vision only (Autopilot currently limited to 80mph, it’s 90mph in our older S and X vehicles with front facing radar; the limitation will be raised once their models are reliable at higher speeds). I expect stationary object detection based on vision eventually, which is not possible with radar alone due to inherent technology limitations.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIt looks like the latest Tesla OS release contains the feature I mentioned (emergency vehicle detection using emergency light detection). New in #Tesla 2021.24.12 Owners Manual for #Model3 #ModelY "If Model 3/Model Y detects lights from an emergency vehicle when using Autosteer at night on a high speed road, the driving speed is automatically reduced and the touchscreen displays a message informing you of the slowdown. You will also hear a chime and see a reminder to keep your hands on the steering wheel. When the light detections pass by or cease to appear, Autopilot resumes your cruising speed. Alternatively, you may tap the accelerator to resume your cruising speed. Never depend on Autopilot features to determine the presence of emergency vehicles. Model 3/Model Y may not detect lights from emergency vehicles in all situations. Keep your eyes on your driving path and always be prepared to take immediate action." https://mobile.twitter.com/analytic_eth/status/1440537502272536581 https://mobile.twitter.com/analytic_eth/status/1440537502272...
- dzhiurgis 5y agowelp. that's absurd - doesn't "the driver wasn't driving safe enough" apply for most of the crashes then?
- avereveard 5y agoa yellow light or a car in front is very well predictable, if you feel you should be slowing down and the car isn't, you have time for apply correction, car not slowing down is an implicit warning of autopilot malfunction you can act upon. a emergency vehicle blocking a tiny fraction of the lane doesn't require as much slowing, you can just slightly move left of your lane to compensate. car not slowing down doesn't trigger the same "brain" warning, because you don't expect it to. this is what sets these crashes aside from the other, you get no explicit and no implicit warning