3 ms·
What are the advantages of building a base in Antarctica? Benefits are fairly nebulous but still real. Building a base in lunar or a halo orbit is pretty stup
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
What are the advantages of building a base in Antarctica? Benefits are fairly nebulous but still real.
Building a base in lunar or a halo orbit is pretty stupid. Very few advantages over earth orbit; substantially higher costs mean we'll use it a lot less.
An earth orbit station has been very useful. However once it ages out the best replacement is probably just fitting out a Starship to orbit for many months and return.
- gus_massa 5y agoThe bases in Antarctica are important because once there is a clear economic incentive, the Antarctic Treaty will end and each country will try to grab a piece. You can let the morons build bases there and nuke them at the last second, but it's more friendly to keep a few bases and use that as a antecedent to pick your part when the negotiations starts.
- wolverine876 5y ago> the Antarctic Treaty will end and each country will try to grab a piece Why not make a new treaty? It couldn't be more clear that it's doable and effective.
- gus_massa 5y agoIn the paper, the treaty if forever. But once there is a clear economical or military reason to have a non scientific base there, the treaty will melt in no time. Imagine that all the nuclear powers (China, France, Russia, United Kingdom, United States, India, North Korea, Pakistan, Israel?, Japan??, South Africa???) decide to split the Antarctica in equally sized pieces. (Perhaps replace North Korea with Germany.) What are the other countries going to do? [Hi from Argentina!] Invade the Antarctica? Launch a conventional war? Blockade Antarctica? An economical blockade of the nuclear powers? Make a very long speech in the UN so the nuclear powers get so bored that decide to return to the previous status?
- wolverine876 5y agoMost international issues are resolved without war these days - and throughout history. That's why it's called the 'Rules-based international order'.
- gus_massa 5y agoI agree. That's why each government force the local mapmakers to include every piece of land they are claiming in the maps, in spite it's controlled by other country, or the legal status is not clear like a piece of the Antarctic. Also, peaceful activities in the are like a research base of a small local population are considered in the discussions. Anyway, in these discussions it's nice to use a photo of your nuclear silos as the background of your video in Zoom. A lot of small border disputes are resolved peacefully, but it's usually about an area that nobody cares too much, or that is small enough that does not justify the cost of a war. > 'Rules-based international order' Yep, but for some unclear reason the first 5 countries in the list have veto power in the UN. IIRC one had nuclear weapons before, and the other 4 decided that making their own nuclear weapons were a good idea. I don't expect this to escalate to a global thermonuclear war. Some countries will just decide to abandon the treaty, occupy whatever part they like, with some negotiation about the border. And perhaps have some conventional naval and terrestrial forces nearby in case it's needed.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Some countries will just decide to abandon the treaty, occupy whatever part they like, with some negotiation about the border. And perhaps have some conventional naval and terrestrial forces nearby in case it's needed. Why? They signed the treaty, and many more, in the first place. > each government force the local mapmakers to include every piece of land they are claiming in the maps They do? It's hard to imagine a democratic government even having that power. > A lot of small border disputes are resolved peacefully, but it's usually about an area that nobody cares too much, or that is small enough that does not justify the cost of a war. Every dispute between democratic countries is resolved without war.
- PeterisP 5y agoWould there be a commercial benefit for an earth orbit station? I believe not at current prices, otherwise companies would have launched one. As soon as you consider private investment (as opposed to essentially charity funding of pure research/exploration), then looking at analogies vs an Antarctic site or deep ocean site may be quite relevant - those are also sites that are somewhat difficult to reach and build on but easier than Moon on Mars; so for any commercial argument in the form of "mining resources" there has to be an answer why suffer the difficulties on the moon instead of (lesser) difficulties in Antarctica.