4 ms·
Does it matter? The only thing that matters to the end user is that the changes they made to their document persist. And they should persist by default, not onl
by bitwize 5y ago
Does it matter? The only thing that matters to the end user is that the changes they made to their document persist. And they should persist by default, not only when the user issues a Save command.
- dylan604 5y agoI don't know, I sort of enjoy being able to make changes, see they didn't work/not necessary/etc, and then just closing the document hitting "Don't save" vs hitting undo until returning to last saved state (which was when exactly???). Bonus points for apps that have an actual Revert feature.
- oneeyedpigeon 5y agoMaybe file management will map closer to revision control one day. Autosave would be the equivalent of a regular commit, closing the document would be a tagged commit of some sort. Your "hitting undo until returning to last saved state" would then be a single step, reverting to a timed, possibly named point.
- dylan604 5y agoFor text based files, I think a versioning like system built into the filesystem would be ideal. Each save is just the diff. A nice UI to see/revert changes. Yet the lack of commit type messages would make those changes less friendly. I don't want to be burdened/slowed down with commit messages everytime I hit Cmd-S. However, this would not work for binary type files like MOV, PSD, etc.
- leohonexus 5y agoAh, this reminds me of YesterCode, a tool that lets you scrub through code changes like a timeline. Relevant HN thread: https://web.eecs.utk.edu/~azh/blog/yestercode.html https://web.eecs.utk.edu/~azh/blog/yestercode.html
- chongli 5y agoStoring diffs is not a great idea since then it requires that you apply them all to get the latest version. Notably, git does not store files as diffs [1] which is one of the reasons it’s so much faster than older diff-based VCSes. [1] https://stackoverflow.com/a/43364484 https://stackoverflow.com/a/43364484
- userbinator 5y agoI was forced to use Microsoft OneNote for a while and it was probably designed by someone with that mentality, and I absolutely HATE it. People manage to put unwanted changes into important pages all the time (the horrible Win10 default of not clearly indicating the focused window is certainly related, but that's another rant...) and the fact that it instantly syncs to the cloud for everyone else to see, made for some major embarrassment and irritation. Changes should be saved with deliberation, not "whenever".