4 ms·
> A lot of people, myself included, would still work Is your current job cleaning gas station toilets at 5am? Because if not, you haven't responded to the pos
by michaelt 5y ago
> A lot of people, myself included, would still work
Is your current job cleaning gas station toilets at 5am?
Because if not, you haven't responded to the posts you're replying to.
- pdimitar 5y agoNo. I have no problem cleaning mine however, or volunteering to clean up parks. Your point?
- nsonha 5y agoTheir point is the people currently working and sustains working such a terrible job will simply stop working, if they can secure the same income. The rest of the time maybe they learn to code (which they can fail), or not and they'll just fuck around. People will definite do something for sure. It's just I'm not sure why something has to be some sort of job or anything beneficial to society. There are a lot of people whose jobs are damaging to society actually.
- pdimitar 5y agoOh, absolutely, I'm not contesting anything that you've said. It's just that I'm fairly sure there will always be people willing to clean toilets for little extra money, especially if they're not abused and kept hostage of a minimum (but lifesaving for them) pay. And those conditions should be impossible in an UBI system.
- hirako2000 5y agoI think you are missing the point: those who do certain jobs only do it to get fed and have shelter. There is no way to make them do it if they had the choice not to do it. The extra money? It wouldn't make enough a difference to climb the ladder, they would try their chance doing something else. That's assuming UBI would actually cover the basics. If that's half the needs to sustain their life I agree they would do that cleaning job, which is getting back to the original situation: job filled only because of lack of choice.
- pdimitar 5y agoWe're talking past each other. I'm not saying it's going to be the same group of people who will re-pick cleaning jobs. There's plenty of people out there who need the occasional physical thankless labor (myself included). As long as it's no more than 3-4h shift IMO there will be people who will do it. In my eyes the key element is having the choice of not doing it. UBI might give us that or it might be a half-arsed measure that only does things on paper. We have no way of knowing that right now though.
- hirako2000 5y agoI can see that scenario yes. I like that aspect of UBI, provide choice to take on those laborious unfulfilling jobs. Looking forward to see a country implementing it, we could the all quit speculating about the outcomes.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoI’m a software engineer and fortunately don’t need to clean bathrooms to feed myself. But to your GP’s point I would for $1 MM per bathroom. While I’m using hyperbole, what it shows is that, there is some non-exploitative wage for cleaning bathrooms and while it might be “too high” for the current business that need clean bathrooms, supply and demand “should” figure out the rest.
- hirako2000 5y agoThe issue is markets are not unregulated, and actors are not all made equals. You wouldn't clean bathrooms for 5 bucks an hour, but others will. And it isn't because they have more affinities with detergents and less distaste for scrubbing dirt.
- josephcsible 5y ago> supply and demand “should” figure out the rest The problem is that the market is being distorted. It used to be that Alice would pay Bob $2000 per month to clean all of the bathrooms in her office. Now, Bob quit his job to live off of $2000 per month of UBI, and Alice's taxes got raised by $2000 per month to help pay for everyone's UBI.
- 6510 5y agoIt's just a job. You go there, do the work then go home again. The misconception is like: Who would want to sit behind a desk all day? Who would want to fill their head with their work and grind puzzles all day the year round even after work and in bed? Endless unproductive meetings? Fight tech debt and deadlines with the wrong tools as if one hand tied behind your back? Never a real vacation? All that for money? What good is it if you don't have time for your own thoughts? One just gets used to it and it isn't a big deal.
- pdimitar 5y agoSure but at least to me personally, one of the goals of UBI is to eliminate the "it's just a job" mindset. People should do what feels fulfilling to them without being slaves of the wage. But for now we can only speculate. I'm still super curious how will the whole thing turn out though!
- 6510 5y agoI share this curiosity. My gut says many positive and many negative things but those are mere speculation. The most negative one is that we have very little choice moving on to a different system. This is one of the few ideas that everyone understands (be it from different perspectives)
- kwhitefoot 5y agoEmployers would finally realize that cleaners provide an important and valuable service and would have to compensate them accordingly. Adam Smith's invisible hand would adjust incomes accordingly.