4 ms·
Our society doesn't welcome people like this anymore. I'm amazed we managed to make use of Mr Parsons at all; just the great luck of having someone in authority
by h2odragon 5y ago
Our society doesn't welcome people like this anymore. I'm amazed we managed to make use of Mr Parsons at all; just the great luck of having someone in authority notice him when they needed a gifted pyromaniac prophet.
- troutwine 5y ago> Amid McCarthyism, Parsons was accused of espionage and left unable to work in rocketry. I would say his own society wasn’t very welcoming of him. As I recall he kept his occult interests mostly under wraps and his career was finished once it no longer was, subsequently dead during the McCarthy era.
- verisimi 5y agoWhat is it is the other way around? That he progressed so far because of his occult roots, but that we don't hear about this sort of thing so much nowadays? PS I personally find it, erm, disconcerting, that someone with a background in magic was able to reach these sorts of heights.
- ethbr0 5y ago> someone with a background in magic was able to reach these sorts of heights Per sibling comment, it doesn't seem surprisingly that someone willing the push the bounds of scientific knowledge also pushed the bounds of thought. And ultimately, that's what experimental science is supposed to be about -- either the thing works or it doesn't. No consideration of the inventor's other qualities. On the other, non-scientific hand, I would have been surprised if he wasn't rejected for a security clearance though!
- gameswithgo 5y agoHe was tuned a bit more open that is ideal, though. And by a bit I mean way way more open.
- Chris2048 5y agoThe though was unconventional, but I wouldn't necessarily say it was innovative - arguably scientific principles are more innovative and unintuitive than the occult philosophies that preceded them. > that's what experimental science is supposed to be about science is supposed to build up knowledge. You shouldn't really be testing things without establishing its basis, otherwise you can't really evaluate the results anyway.
- ethbr0 5y agoI think that ordering is a modern science vs early science distinction. Most of the early principles of gravity, motion, electricity, and magnetism were observed and experimentally tested before having a basis to evaluate them. Heck, even quantum mechanics was (and arguably, still is, in un-unified form) experimentally characterized before an explanation (see: double-slit results).
- Chris2048 5y agosure, but the occult appears to take e.g. the existence of certain spirits/deities as granted, despite having no experimental confirmation. How would a ritual dependant on such lore be objective?
- roenxi 5y agoHumans rely heavily on social proof and familiarity to make decisions. There is social pressure to be normal and stick with the herd or only try small innovations on or close to the bounds of acceptable thought. But in contrast it is difficult to make serious contributions to state-of-the-art without being some combination of insane, obsessive or twisted. It can be done, but someone who just wants to set fire to everything is just going to learn more about fire than everyone else. While normal people don't learn how to do abnormal things. The whole trick is setting up a society where strange people can make outsized constructive contributions even if society at large is trying to hit them with all the bullying tools it uses to make people stand in line. That is part of why liberty is so important, and why it is necessary to accept people even if they are just wrong about a belief.
- Chris2048 5y ago> a society where strange people can make outsized constructive contributions even if society at large is trying to hit them with all the bullying tools it uses to make people stand in line This is a huge generalisations: what "bulling tools" and what "strange"-ness? Social pressure can be used for bad, but it can also be used for good - it binds the fabric of society together. There's that principle in tech of "not tolerating assholes/toxic people". How does someone strange differ (according to all opinions" from a (perceived) asshole?
- roenxi 5y ago> not tolerating assholes/toxic people Both of those descriptions are metaphorical. I don't know what you mean, and neither do most of the people reading the comment because different people use the words very differently. So while I do put in an effort to respond to questions in this case I cannot.
- Chris2048 5y agoI'm not sure they are metaphorical, beyond the sense that nearly all words are. But in any case, isn't it the point that this is subjective? But so is what constitutes a "strange [person]". Is an anti-vaxer "strange", or an "asshole"? It's not like every society is based on well defined unambiguous rules, sometimes (not) sticking to convention is what discriminates the geniuses and serial killers alike.