3 ms·
Although I agree with your logic, I suspect that consumers are extremely price sensitive so shoes in the same category are roughly the same price & it makes sen
by roenxi 5y ago
Although I agree with your logic, I suspect that consumers are extremely price sensitive so shoes in the same category are roughly the same price & it makes sense to talk about %.
Shoemakers are already charging what they believe to be the highest price they can regardless of costs. They don't believe they can raise the price, or they already would have.
- BobbyJo 5y ago> Shoemakers are already charging what they believe to be the highest price they can regardless of costs. They don't believe they can raise the price, or they already would have. The highest price you can charge for shoes made in China is different than that of shoes made in the USA. Whether or not it's enough to support a market is a different question, but it's an undeniable difference. Personally, I'm willing to pay around 2X to get American made goods, and routinely go out of my way to do so.
- roenxi 5y ago> Personally, I'm willing to pay... Unfortunately, the consumers who matters is the rather less well off one who is making decisions based on how much money they have in their bank account today. A number which is rarely large, if the stats are to be believed. I agree with the sentiment. But I'm overpaid. Most people aren't willing to double their expenses on something because they want to support a political outcome. They would quickly run out of money.
- zarzavat 5y agoOr rather people will buy one thing made in $HOMECOUNTRY, get their dopamine hit from supporting the motherland, and then proceed to buy everything else from China.
- angio 5y agoAs a european I wouldn't pay twice for american made shoes, while I (and many people) routinely pay a premium for italian and french made shoes. The problem is that made in america is not considered premium for clothes the same way that made in italy or france is.
- BobbyJo 5y agoI was in my #AMERICAn frame of mind writing that comment. I was thinking along the lines of "Not produced by an adversarial country, slave labor, or a country with relaxed environment regulation." It's the reason why so many products advertise 'sustainability' or 'fair trade'. It differentiates the product. I was trying to make the general point that how items are produced does actually matter to consumers, and a large population are willing to pay for moral manufacturing, myself included.
- a9h74j 5y agoI'd suggest shoe[maker] to table to reduce total margins, but that has connotations of Charlie Chaplan.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoLook at what Sneaker Heads pay for shoes. It's rediculious, and it's not just Nike's. On Nike's side, I see it at pure greed. For what they charge, they could pay an American Worker $40/hr, plus medical? (Yes--I pulled that $40 out my arse.) My sister has two shoe stores in LA. She made everything here prior to Covid. She paid her employees $10/hr, and offered zero benefits. Pre-covid she was a multimillionaire. (To anyone selling a craft, don't skimp on stuff people throw away, like bags, tissue, fancy price tags. It's about branding. Oh yea, sometimes the higher the price--the more they want it. My sister is a cutthroat businesswoman. I always knew she would be wealthy. She's not a great person though.)
- odiroot 5y ago> Look at what Sneaker Heads pay for shoes. It's rediculious, and it's not just Nike's. They pay for the hype not for the quality.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoMinimum wage in CA has been more than $10 per hour since Jan 1, 2017. I also find it highly unlikely an employer would have found a $10 per hour worker in LA even 10 years ago. Not sure what sneaker heads have to do with anything, as they are not a meaningful portion of the broad market for shoes. Nike has a ~10% profit margin, and that would be a liberal definition of pure greed, relative to other businesses’ profit margins. Especially considering they have no lock in or moat for their product other than people’s individual desire to buy them.
- lovecg 5y agoHint: lax border enforcement combined with draconian immigration law creates opportunities for wage arbitrage.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThose factors are not in play in upscale shoe stores in LA. And I would still ascribe a low probability of finding even an under the table or illegal immigrant $10 per hour in LA in the last 10 years.