3 ms·
Out of interest, do you believe you the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan was a win or loss for the USSR?
by lostlogin 5y ago
Out of interest, do you believe you the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan was a win or loss for the USSR?
- torstenvl 5y agoApples and oranges. The topic under discussion is military tech and military ability. The strategic victories or blunders of civilian leadership and diplomatic corps are just as important -- indeed often moreso -- but they are somewhat orthogonal to military strength. There are only a couple ways to lose a battle, but countless ways to lose a war.
- lostlogin 5y agoThat’s exactly my point - of course the former USSR and current US have a more powerful military than anything that exists or existed in Afghanistan. It wasn’t solely a military problem but both chose a primarily military solution (as did the British before them).
- torstenvl 5y agoYou appear to be disagreeing with my disagreement with "the us couldn't win a fight with a bunch of villagers with ak47 for 10 years" How does your point support the original claim? You and I are in agreement that fighting alone can't solve the problem of Afghanistan, but I don't see how that bears any relationship to judging the fighting.
- lostlogin 5y agoSorry, I’ve completely missed your point (despite reading it. Sigh), and as you say, I’m agreeing with you. I’ll leave my comments unedited unless you’d like them gone.
- torstenvl 5y agoNot at all, brother, I appreciate the mutual respect and engagement. Thanks for making HN a great place :-)