5 ms·
a clever friend once said it this way, while I was complaining about the GIMP interface. He said "Adobe spent years refining the small details of Photoshop, and
by mistrial9 5y ago
a clever friend once said it this way, while I was complaining about the GIMP interface. He said "Adobe spent years refining the small details of Photoshop, and GIMP must not copy PS, so therefore all the GIMP interface parts will feel terrible, by default"
of course this is humorous oversimplification, but I can't help but think of it every time I really, really need a general editor, open GIMP and immediately start cursing over ordinary thing.
source: I wrote the third color paint app for the Mac II thirty years ago while a contractor at Apple Inc.
- mrj 5y agoThere's no limit on copying from PS, but it wouldn't make sense to trash the current user base to try to acquire those used to PS. Then it would be the Gimp users who feel upset.
- RubyRidgeRandy 5y agoSomething that others might not be aware of - Gimp could be a lot better by now, but Adobe actually has patents on features that cannot be included into Gimp, including certain UI elements. So there is a limit on what Gimp can do, not because of competency, but because of legality.
- luegen 5y agoIs there by any chance a list of software patents that Adobe or other companies hold that GIMP cannot implement for this reason?
- prokoudine 5y agoThere is no such thing because patents have nothing to do with this.
- TheRealNGenius 5y agoAgree, Rubyridge is just flat-out wrong. Check out photo pea for example, UI is remarkably similar to photoshop
- RubyRidgeRandy 5y agohttps://patents.justia.com/assignee/adobe-systems-inc https://patents.justia.com/assignee/adobe-systems-inc content aware stamp tool METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR SELECTIVE SYNCHRONIZATION OF A DISPLAY LAYOUT METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR GESTURE BASED COPYING OF ATTRIBUTES METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR AN IMPROVED WORKFLOW FOR DIGITAL IMAGE EDITING Construction of multimedia compositions Methods and apparatus for selecting objects by state Methods and apparatus for automatically grouping graphical constructs Methods and apparatus for maintaining online preferences Methods and apparatus for creating a quick canvas System and method for identifying Bezier curves from a shape Method and apparatus for applying locale behaviors to regions of a form Preview window including a storage context view of one or more computer resources Methods and apparatus for arranging graphical objects Methods and apparatus to identify graphical elements Methods and apparatus for three-dimensional isographic navigation System for manipulating noise in digital images Compound layers for composited image manipulation Method of color selection for display and printing
- prokoudine 5y ago> Something that others might not be aware of - Gimp could be a lot better by now, but Adobe actually has patents on features that cannot be included into Gimp, including certain UI elements. It's an urban legend :) Improving UX means we need 1) UX architects/designers — got none 2) developers to implement what UX people design — got too few
- RubyRidgeRandy 5y agohttps://patents.justia.com/assignee/adobe-systems-inc https://patents.justia.com/assignee/adobe-systems-inc content aware stamp tool METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR SELECTIVE SYNCHRONIZATION OF A DISPLAY LAYOUT METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR GESTURE BASED COPYING OF ATTRIBUTES METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR AN IMPROVED WORKFLOW FOR DIGITAL IMAGE EDITING Construction of multimedia compositions Methods and apparatus for selecting objects by state Methods and apparatus for automatically grouping graphical constructs Methods and apparatus for maintaining online preferences Methods and apparatus for creating a quick canvas System and method for identifying Bezier curves from a shape Method and apparatus for applying locale behaviors to regions of a form Preview window including a storage context view of one or more computer resources Methods and apparatus for arranging graphical objects Methods and apparatus to identify graphical elements Methods and apparatus for three-dimensional isographic navigation System for manipulating noise in digital images Compound layers for composited image manipulation Method of color selection for display and printing
- prokoudine 5y agoNone of that is the reason for a missing feature. Some of those things are actually implemented in GIMP, at least, judging by titles. Like I said, urban legend.
- ryantgtg 5y agoMy clever take is that complaining about GIMP’s UI is just a meme at this point. I could easily complain about Photoshop or Illustrator’s UI just as much as GIMP or Inkscape.
- reginold 5y agoYeah I'm curious what exactly makes GIMP different. Photoshop and Pixelmator are bot pretty similar to use on a Mac. Is it just the layout of buttons? Or is there some "first principles" difference in the design of GIMP vs Photoshop? Is GIMP made for programmers and Photoshop for designers?
- ryantgtg 5y agoNo, GIMP is for designers, too. I use Photoshop at work and GIMP at home. Both for very light work. Adding text to an image, putting a product into a mockup template, resizing, etc. Both programs are very similar - I don’t really notice much difference between them. And GIMP does some things better! Like any program, there’s a learning curve. But there are lots of like-for-like features and layout choices between the two, so if you know one then the other is easy to adapt to.
- p0nce 5y agoIs it Stockhold syndrome? After years of GIMP I really disliked the Affinity interface, also it is unusably slow on a very recent computer here. I kinda like GIMP, the good parts.
- klondike_klive 5y agoIs that an egg-corn? ie an mishearing of a well-known phrase in a way that makes total sense? Stockhold syndrome - it's like Stockholm syndrome but you're cheerleading for companies with crappy products only because you own stock.