3 ms·
At best an academic question in matters like this. This is rather directly comparable to an 'independent' US commission taking umbrage at something Huawei has d
by roenxi 5y ago
At best an academic question in matters like this. This is rather directly comparable to an 'independent' US commission taking umbrage at something Huawei has done.
On the one hand, maybe it is an independent action. On the other hand, there are so many considerations around security, geopolitics and nationalism that it is hard to even know what they are meant to be independent of.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> an 'independent' US commission taking umbrage at something Huawei has done Which scarequotes-independent commission are you referring to?
- roenxi 5y agoA hypothetical one. I'm not aware of any independent commission looking in to Huawei, and I'd have contempt for its alleged independence if there is one. Put it another way. If we carbon-copied Google into a Chinese firm with nothing changed about their operations it would be a crisis in the US and probably discovered to be breach all sorts of laws. The pervasive spying that Google must be doing for the NSA alone would be a crisis, ignoring the broader strategic issues. It would be infeasible for any aspect of any resistance to this hypothetical Sinoogle to be free from political interference, the stakes would be too high. Shutting it down in the US at a minimum and ideally globally would be a priority 1 goal for the US establishment. With that as table stakes, what does it mean for a commission to be independent? If it looks like the commission will come to a politically unsatisfactory conclusion laws will change and new commissioners would be found.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> A hypothetical one. I'm not aware of any independent commission looking in to Huawei Because there hasn't been one. The claim that the CCI probe is "comparable to an 'independent' US commission taking umbrage at...Huawei" is baseless within this context. (If anything, comparing geopolitical actions against Huawei with the CCI's is an argument against the probe's independence.)
- DetroitThrow 5y agoOkay, your first comment is useless for everyone trying to figure out how politically independent the CCI is from the executive branch because you're just jumping to bring up Huawei. This isn't an interesting contribution to the discussion, just a long form approach to bring up your entirely unrelated political grievances.