2 ms·
I recall on rule of fixing a market problem is to apply the most direct fix possible. The government would be better off just giving money directly to renters
by refurb 5y ago
I recall on rule of fixing a market problem is to apply the most direct fix possible.
The government would be better off just giving money directly to renters to pay their rent.
This has the added benefit that the cost of subsidy of very transparent and it provides a nice incentive to increase housing supply.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoI, as a taxpayer, refuse to finance a few lucky grandfathered-in people that want to live in a highly sought-after district but cannot afford the rent. There is no human right to an apartment in the city center of a megapolis.
- refurb 5y agoBut it’s no different than your tax dollars buying housing from private entities or building public housing and charging lower than market rent. It’s all dollars out of your pocket.
- dredmorbius 5y agoLand is an inelastic good. "Buy land. They ain't makin' any more of the stuff." -- Will Rogers In economics, rents are goods or services whose supply is inelastic (doesn't increase when demand increases), so that any increase in demand simply results in a rise in price. Another way of looking at this is that all surplus value of that service is appropriated by the seller. This contrasts to normal commodity goods in which price tends to fall to the cost of provisioning. Note that wages generally behave this way as well, with the result that unskilled workers (lacking any wage premium) in a rents-based world are squeezed between wages which deny them all surplus value of labour and rents which appropriate all surplus value of housing. Any increase in wages is immediately met by a corresponding increase in rents. Your proposal of a direct rent subsidy is the equivalent of a wage increase. You'll pay it to the workers, who'll in turn pass it on directly to the landlords. Counterintuitively: if you want to lower the cost of housing, tax the unimproved value of land. Where regulation allows for increased utilisation density, the result is that the tax (as with the wage increase) is passed on to landlords. It effectively takes up the surplus value of housing, and appropriates it for public expenditure. Landlord profits are reduced. Landlords can increase profits by increasing the real estate units available --- by building more units on the same land. This means one or more of less unbuilt land per property (setbacks and easements), smaller units (more people in a given space), or more floors. Building two storeys rather than one doubles the available real estate. Building up 5 or 10 storeys increases land by a factor of 5 or 10. (It's not necessary to build cloud-scraping towers, even modest increases in height limits will greatly increase housing densities.) Housing is a good for which increasing taxes, if done correctly, INCREASES supply. Highly counterintuitive, but true. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax