4 ms·
That's a good approach, thanks for writing it as a reminder. This takes me back to math and physics lessons, where we tested a given function/formula at extreme
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
That's a good approach, thanks for writing it as a reminder. This takes me back to math and physics lessons, where we tested a given function/formula at extremes and one or more interesting points in the middle, just to get a good feel for its behavior.
Continuing your mental framework, the problem with interpreting such research is that the results we get are in the "probe some points to get a feel" category. Consider a single learning style, and let's plot its known effectiveness, as a function of "learning capability", where "learning capability" is a measure that places students with relevant disabilities on the left, and students with relevant gifts on the right. Assume, for the sake of the exercise, that this metric is sound. We get something like:
EFFECTIVENESS
^
| oo
| x x x
|
|oo
+--------------------------------->
LEARNING CAPACITY
Where 'o' are obvious values derived from the thought experiments like you did ("what happens if a student cannot hear?", etc.), and 'x' are points from research of the method over a population of a given learning capacity. Looking at 'x' points alone would make you think the method doesn't improve anything for anyone. Looking at 'o' points alone would make you conclude it obviously is effective. But the points I depicted above are not enough to tell you whether the function looks like this:
EFFECTIVENESS
^ ***
| ***
| ************************
| **
|**
+--------------------------------->
LEARNING CAPACITY
Or like this:
EFFECTIVENESS
^ *******
| *******
| *******
| ********
|****
+--------------------------------->
LEARNING CAPACITY
Or something else entirely. This is something to keep in mind too: does the research data you saw, whether from single or multiple studies, sampled enough of the search space to give you some confidence in the conclusions?
- eitland 5y agoThanks! Good points!