4 ms·
> I know there is no handbook for peace What does peace look like to you? Do people just stop fighting and start loving their neighbours? You mentioned Jerusa
by dotancohen 5y ago
> I know there is no handbook for peace
What does peace look like to you? Do people just stop fighting and start loving their neighbours?
You mentioned Jerusalem. I'm Israeli, so I'm biased towards one side of the Jerusalem story but let me try to frame the other side of the story as to not play my biases. I probably won't be accurate because my propaganda is different from their propaganda. And I won't reply because this will otherwise turn into a flamewar real quick.
Does peace mean to you that the Palestinians stop fighting for a state of their own? They just raise their hands, lay down their guns, and embrace Jewish rule? Should they accept your $2 trillion - the number that you stated to invest in the peace project - as reparations for loosing their olive groves, villages, and roads to Israeli settlers? Will that be enough for them to embrace no public transportation on Saturdays, even though their culture would have it be Fridays? Will that be enough to forgive the years that cousin Ahmad sat in an Israeli prison? Will that be enough to forget the eye or leg or life that cousin Mahmaud lost?
And what of the five million people whose grandfathers either fled or were chased from Palestine in 1947? Should they accept some slice of the cash and relinquish their dream of returning to Palestine? Sure, some of them live in the US or Italy or the UK with their nice standard of living. But some of them live in refugee camps - to this day - in Lebanon and Syria and they have no rights in those countries. Under your peace plan, what becomes of a child in Yarmouk, whose family has been forbidden from education, health care, and most forms of work for three generations? Does he take that slice of $2 trillion and now buy a house in Syria? Forbidden to him. In the UK? He doesn't even qualify for a passport. In Palestine? Palestine has not enough land to quadruple its population. In Israel? To live under _their_ laws?!?!? What if Palestine and Israel are a single entity under this plan... does that make the situation easier or more difficult?
In my opinion, some problems just cannot be solved with money.
- scoopertrooper 5y ago> Will that be enough for them to embrace no public transportation on Saturdays, even though their culture would have it be Fridays? Crazy idea. Jews drive/catch public transportation on Fridays, muslims drive/catch transportation on Saturdays, and the rest of us ride around everyday of the week, because in what world is any of this a good idea?
- achow 5y agoIn the world where transportation staff does not need atleast 1d/week day off.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoCrazy idea, some employees take certain days off while others take different days off. You know, like how every other critical industry operates operates, and how public transportation works in countries that don't shut it down once a week.
- dsr_ 5y agoAnd how it already operates with a shift system, since driving heavy machinery full of people around cities for more than six hours a day is rather dangerous, but people like to be able to get around all day. All drivers get two days a week off, one of them being their preference for Friday/Saturday/Sunday and the other not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- achow 5y agoThat is assuming that there is demand for those service in the days where otherwise it would have been shut down (Sun or Fri or Sat). If a place ~90% shuts down on a particular day, running a skeleton service with limited staff may not be viable due to the fact that most of the infra needs to be nearly 100% operational to support skeleton crews and vehicles. And also it may involve lot of planning to run skeleton operations (for all you know 10% of the users are sprinkled all over the grid - so which all routes you run the skeleton service, at what frequency etc.).
- scoopertrooper 5y agoAgain, this is a solved problem in countries that keep things moving every day of the week. For instance, trains may be replaced by busses on those days or bus routes may operate at reduced capacity.
- scns 5y agoThank you for your perspective. One tip though, stop assuming a flamewar (which the awesome mods [shoutout to @dang, you rock!] would smother respectfully) this site is known and cherished for its' civilized discourse.
- EMM_386 5y ago> What does peace look like to you? Do people just stop fighting and start loving their neighbours? It would look a lot more like regional conflicts without $1 billion each fighter jets. Iron Dome, drones and other technology prove this can be handled regionally without the need for a single advanced fighter jet, ballistic missile submarine, or any of these other frankly absurd expenditures. The work force dedicated to these (admittedly very impressive) weapons of war would have to focus their skills elsewhere.
- spullara 5y agoI can agree with you except for the ballistic missile submarine. Mutually assured destruction is what keeps conflicts regional.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> What does peace look like to you? Peace is what the United States has had with Vietnam since 1975. How can we understand that, when the reason for going to war, at the cost of 58,000 American lives, was that without an intervention, the domino theory predicted that the world order would inevitably collapse? It didn't. Vietnam, notwithstanding the pandemic, is a tourist destination where 18 year old American kids have the time of their live in complete safety. Money for peace would investigate this outcome with the aim of advancing our theoretical knowledge so we might get it right next time, in time to avoid conflict.
- eitland 5y agoProblem is the West had just experienced the failure that was to try to make peace with a mad dictator (Hitler) a few decades before. Also the Communists were quite open about their plans for world domination.
- wombatmobile 5y agoHitler was killed in 1945. Are you saying the West was unable to distinguish between Hitler and other world leaders, 20 years later? That sounds like a cognitive bias, akin to PTSD. Surely it would be better for the world to develop therapies for that cognitive bias instead of going to war. > Also the Communists were quite open about their plans for world domination. Didn't the Russians defeat Hitler, at the cost of 22 million Russian casualties? What plans for world domination are you referring to? Can you point to any act of armed aggression by the Russians against a Western government? Can you point to any act of armed aggression by the Chinese Communist Part against a western government?
- wombatmobile 5y agoPeople who prefer peace to war know what kind of people downvote comments like this without offering a substantive response.
- eitland 5y ago> Are you saying the West was unable to distinguish between Hitler and other world leaders, 20 years later? Stalin was almost every bit as bad as Hitler and outlasted him by almost a decade. Others were just as bad just less "successful". Also, after a painful lesson in dealing with mad dictators I'm actually glad the west didn't forget the lesson so fast. > Didn't the Russians defeat Hitler, at the cost of 22 million Russian casualties? I give you this, this is partially true: They absolutely played a huge part in it but were themselves saved by Churchill after doing the same blunder as the west: trusting Hitler. > What plans for world domination are you referring to? Please do read up on the history of international Communism and Socialism. > Can you point to any act of armed aggression by the Russians against a Western government? Besides numerous proxy wars, occupying half of Europe, and, more recently starting a war against Ukraine and shooting down MH-17? > Can you point to any act of armed aggression by the Chinese Communist Part against a western government? They haven't dared that quite yet as far as I know but they've broken the agreement with Britain about Hong Kong quite thoroughly, they keep stealing fish (note: the west has also been guilty of this).
- eitland 5y agoThat was a mightily impressive performance of looking at the problem through someone elses eyes! Favorited!
- setum 5y ago$2 trillions could have been used to convert Palestinians into Jews, Christians, Jains or Buddhists, peacefully of-course. While it may not have resolved all the conflicts, it definitely would have reduced it drastically.