3 ms·
> I was struck by how big the gaps are in our knowledge of the vaccine. Most of what you describe is not just "knowledge of the vaccine", it's "knowledge about
by mschuster91 5y ago
> I was struck by how big the gaps are in our knowledge of the vaccine.
Most of what you describe is not just "knowledge of the vaccine", it's "knowledge about how immune systems actually work". For example, we still have no certain knowledge about how measles manages to wipe out your immune system.
Most of medicine is (although often very good!) guesswork.
> 2. The vaccine's effects on transmission are not clear.
Indeed, but the vaccine's effects on infection are clear. Less infected people automatically means less people transmitting the virus.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoDid you even listen to the panel? You seem to be casually dismissing issues that the members themselves raised.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe issues described (or rather, the lack of knowledge that is at the bottom of these issues) are not new, they are true for many, many forms of medicine we use today. ffs we don't even know how exactly virtually all medicine used in treatment of mental illnesses such as schizophrenia and depression work - most medical treatments consist of trying all available candidates and varying the dosage until you find a somewhat effective one - and yet we accept this lack of knowledge. As for what this means for vaccines: It is by now widely accepted that a vaccination drastically reduces the effects of a COVID19 infection and all but eliminates the risk of fatal outcomes and that in billions of people vaccinated by billions of doses of various vaccines the side effects were negligibly small, and it is widely accepted that even in young healthy people, COVID19 can cause severe, even long-term cases. Therefore, the potential risks of vaccination are nowhere near as risky as risking the infection with the actual pathogen.
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago> As for what this means for vaccines: It is by now widely accepted that a vaccination drastically reduces the effects of a COVID19 infection and all but eliminates the risk of fatal outcomes and that in billions of people vaccinated by billions of doses of various vaccines the side effects were negligibly small, and it is widely accepted that even in young healthy people, COVID19 can cause severe, even long-term cases. Therefore, the potential risks of vaccination are nowhere near as risky as risking the infection with the actual pathogen. The vaccination discussion you're trying to have has already been settled. The panel was not revisiting the approved 2-dose course. It was considering the benefits and risks of a third (booster) jab for individuals aged 16 and above. If you had listened to the panel, you'd understand the vote: there is not enough data at this time to conclude that the benefits outweigh the risks for a booster in such a broad group.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt also seems patently obvious that in order for the vaccinated immune system to destroy the virus, one must first have the virus in the body, i.e. be infected with the virus. This will take a non-zero amount of time. Hence, a vaccinated person can in the interim test positive for the virus, even if the vaccine protection is working perfectly fine.
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agoNot necessarily so from what I've read about neutralizing antibodies. You'll only have a lot of them for a while after an exposure, but if they latch onto, in this case, every spike protein on the surface of a SARS-CoV-2 virus, the virus will never get a chance to infect a cell. Antibodies latched onto surface proteins can also stick to each other and form clumps that limit or eliminate the ability to infect. Otherwise you're correct as far as I know, the other mechanisms of the adaptive immune system only come into play once cells get infected. But there might not be very many of them, perhaps not enough for a RT-PCR test to find.