5 ms·
This is a pretty weak accusation. It was quite obvious watching the program that they were aware the battery was running low (they commented on the "miles left
by eli 15y ago
This is a pretty weak accusation.
It was quite obvious watching the program that they were aware the battery was running low (they commented on the "miles left" meter several times). They more-or-less willfully ran out of juice in a small town. So what.
The point wasn't that the car can only go 60km versus 100km on a charge, or whatever the numbers. The point was that the car has a range limit, that the limit is not terribly far, that the car takes a while to charge when it dies, and there aren't many charging stations.
Perhaps Top Gear was a bit hyperbolic to make that point (Consumer Reports they are not), but these are all fair points.
I'm sorry. I'm all about calling out bias where I see it, but this just smacks of a car maker trying to spin some largely legitimate complaints with their product.
Not many people could get away with owning a plug-in electric as their only car. Even if it were half as much as a comparable gas car (rather than twice as much). As Clarkson said in the episode, the leaf is actually a really nice ca and electric is obviously the future, but today it is just not practical.
- fossuser 15y ago>Not many people could get away with owning a plug-in electric as their only car. This is actually the myth that Top Gear seems interested in forever perpetuating. Most people don't drive that far (http://news.discovery.com/autos/range-anxiety-nissan-leaf-110715.html http://news.discovery.com/autos/range-anxiety-nissan-leaf-11...) I think Chevy determined the average daily driver drives around 40 miles. The range of these new electric vehicles are actually fine for the majority of people's daily drivers and are only going to get better. For long drives they're not a good choice yet (since the infrastructure doesn't yet exist and without something like battery swap charging takes too long). >The point wasn't that the car can only go 60km versus 100km on a charge, or whatever the numbers. The point was that the range has a limit, that the limit is not that far... Was that really the point? You don't see them driving a gasoline powered car near empty and then acting confused when it can't reach it's destination while suggesting that gasoline powered cars are not the future. I think they went past hyperbolic into misleading.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- fossuser 15y agoTrue, but small and dense also works in favor of an EV. The car tells you it's charge and uses GPS to determine if you can make it to your destination so you don't run out along the way. I suppose my point is running out of charge isn't something that would happen by accident and acting like it is can be misleading.
- jodrellblank 15y ago[I deleted my comment as a duplicate of Eli's before seeing you had replied. For the record, I said] Was that really the point? You don't see them driving a gasoline powered car near empty and then acting confused when it can't reach it's destination Because that's not such a problem - partly because you can walk to the nearest petrol station, and bring back a can of petrol and get going again, and partly because the UK is small and dense with petrol stations everywhere (try Google Maps UK and search for Petrol Station - 5 miles will probably get you to one, 20 miles almost certainly).
- MikeCapone 15y agoOff the top of my head, 80% of drivers drive less than 40 miles/day in the US, and that number is probably much lower in Europe and Asia. Since cars spend most of the day parked somehwere, you have lots of opportunities to plug an EV in, and so most times when you drive off you have a full battery.
- overgard 15y ago> Since cars spend most of the day parked somehwere, you have lots of opportunities to plug an EV in Maybe in theory, but how many outside wall outlets do you see, and who's paying for the electricity?
- 15y ago
- dagw 15y agoNot many people could get away with owning a plug-in electric as their only car. Even if it were half as much as a comparable gas car (rather than twice as much). Why not? If an electric car was half the price of a petrol car, then there's no way I would not buy one, and then just rent a car those times i need to drive far.