3 ms·
I was just having a conversation with a friend of mine and talking about a similar thing: we just aren't looking for life as broadly as we might. To a certain e
by cratermoon 5y ago
I was just having a conversation with a friend of mine and talking about a similar thing: we just aren't looking for life as broadly as we might. To a certain extent, it's excusable, because how do you search for something you can't even properly recognize if you found it? How do you decide you've detected life if it doesn't fit any definition of life you can be confident of?
Looking for earth-like planets and trying to detect signs of life as we know it might eventually bear fruit, but whatever life is there is likely to resemble earth around the time life emerged on land a relatively recent 400 million years ago. The signs of life won't be alien structures, but biochemical signatures. What about the other 4 billion years, when Earth's life existed only in the oceans? On cosmic time scales, that's far more likely, but do we know enough about what Earth looked like to recognize that on exoplanets?
Projects that attempt to detect advanced extra-terrestrial life by their electromagnetic emissions, like SETI, seem especially misguided. We've only had the ability to broadcast radio for 100 years or so. That's laughably short on cosmic time scales, and the distances they've propagated are insignificant even on just a galactic scale. Just 75 other systems exist within that tiny distance, and our signals are likely distorted and attenuated to the point of being indistinguishable from background noise for most of them.
The book I like to recommend is titled Life Beyond Earth: The Intelligent Earthling’s Guide to Life in the Universe by Gerald and Feinberg and Robert Shapiro and published in 1980. It speculates on what forms life could take and how we might know something is living even if it doesn't fit our conventional ideas of life as we know it.