2 ms·
Just because there are shades of grey, doesn’t mean we can’t tell black from white.
by michaelt 5y ago
Just because there are shades of grey, doesn’t mean we can’t tell black from white.
- eldaisfish 5y agoit's an excellent question which your reply doesn't address. There's black and white with grey in between. Whether you report the shades of grey as black or white depends on who you ask and what is offered for comparison. Is india an authoritarian regime? You'll find plenty of evidence going both ways. What about Belarus? Hungary? Venezuela? The grey is precisely why having yes/no binaries like this leads to more confusion.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI am not convinced that we can tell black from white. I also think that there ought to be a certain level of relativism when it comes to judging political systems. Is it democratic that an unelected group of 9 people can unilaterally essentially decide the law of the land in the US?
- lovecg 5y agoHow is the US constitutional system remotely relevant in this discussion?
- whimsicalism 5y agoBecause every political system has elements of "authoritarianism"/decisions being made by unelected officials. For instance, we often criticize Iran as being authoritarian, but compared to many of our allies elsewhere, Iran is actually relatively democratic, even if they have authoritarian "checks" just like we do with the Supreme Court.
- lovecg 5y agoI have a hard time understanding what you mean about Iran: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Leader_of_Iran https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Leader_of_Iran Seems like a dictatorship to me.
- yanderekko 5y ago>Is it democratic that an unelected group of 9 people can unilaterally essentially decide the law of the land in the US? Are republican (little r) systems inherently authoritarian in your view? Do you actually fear that SCOTUS is going to start imposing some sort of autocratic control over American government? I'm not. You probably aren't either. There are institutional explanations for this.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI actually consider myself a staunch (little r) republican. That said, Machiavelli's Discourses on Livy (a seminal republican text) was quite clear that republican mixed government does involve mixing a bit of democracy with a bit of authoritarianism/autocracy. I do think it is "authoritarian", but I don't think it is necessarily bad. My question is merely: why can we extend this sort of support to mixed government in our country, but seemingly consider many of the other forms of mixed government in action as pure authoritarian tyranny?
- klyrs 5y agoI would describe qualified immunity as starkly autocratic, and it was written whole-cloth by the supreme court.