5 ms·
Groupon is a legitimate business, which sells a real product for real money, in a manner that attempts to generate value for customers in a two-sided marketplac
by patio11 15y ago
Groupon is a legitimate business, which sells a real product for real money, in a manner that attempts to generate value for customers in a two-sided marketplace. It is an exceptionally risky business, like every other startup that aspires to the trajectory of "Go from nowhere to selling a billion dollars of product in two years."
It is entirely possible investors will get burned in an extraordinary fashion on Groupon. It is also possible they will end up with money hats. Capitalism happens. If capitalism happening to you would negatively impact your ability to feed your family, do not buy stock in Groupon. (Do not buy any individual stocks, either.)
With regards to their accounting practices: I'm agnostic as to whether any particular treatment of another company's numbers is maximally reflective of the interests of third-parties wishing to invest in them. That said, have you noticed we are not exactly a paint-within-the-lines industry?
Heck, even answering very freaking simple questions with intent to be maximally honest while complying with all regulations gets very difficult. For example, when do you think you can recognize revenue for selling someone $10 for 1,000 gold coins if they then immediately spend 500 gold coins on a Sword of Dragonslaying? If you have not read about this specific case before, I guarantee your first three guesses are wrong. Or, to pick an example near and dear to my heart, what exactly is getting sold when you take $29.95 from a customer and mark their account as Registered? Is it real property? If so, where is that property sold? "The location that a customer takes delivery", swell: do they "take delivery" at my business or at my server or at their home address or at their place of work? Is it perhaps not a real property and instead royalties? Is it a fee for a service? Oh, that depends on whether customization and support is offered: how much support is support? Answering emails is support if I make changes to the product on the basis of them?
I have given tax offices on two continents head-explosions just with the accounting for BCC. This stuff is hard.
- michaelchisari 15y agoCapitalism happens. Except that the net economic effect of this kind of reckless activity and their subsequent collapse extends to people who have no idea what a Groupon is or does. If it was a system that touched only those who actively engaged with Groupon, it would be a different story. But that's not how things work.
- teej 15y agoI think you've woefully misunderstood the issue at hand here. No one is claiming that Groupon isn't a real business. They've made a household name and their reach is undeniable. Many of us have paid out of our pockets to buy from Groupon. I know I have. No one is saying that investing isn't dangerous. The market has always worked this way and Groupon is no exception. Recognizing & reporting revenue for software and virtual goods is a -solved problem-. Take a look at EA's earnings report or Zynga's IPO filing if you want to understand how the big boys do it. The accounting required is certainly tricky, but it's also widely accepted and tied to reality. While Zynga's profitabilty in the future is uncertain, their profitabilty right now is NOT. ==================== There are two core issues with the Groupon filing: * Their use of ASCOI grossly misrepresented their profitability -right now-. They may have an innovative business, but the way they handle money isn't that different. Certainly not different enough for them to invent new ways to report earnings. Thankfully, the SEC agrees with me here and has asked Groupon to redo some of their funny math. * Their last round of financing almost ENTIRELY went to cashing out previous investors. That has nothing to do with "taxes being hard". It has everything to do with sketchy business practices. In conclusion - Groupon's filing isn't scary because IPO's are hard. Groupon's filing is scary because they were a little TOO creative with their math and they've done some undesirable things with their cash in the last 6 months.
- timack 15y ago"Their last round of financing almost ENTIRELY went to cashing out previous investors." Sounds a bit like a Ponzi scheme.
- Cushman 15y agoSounds almost entirely like a Ponzi scheme.
- zwieback 15y agoFor a Ponzi scheme to work it's important that the early investors not cash out for a long time. They see their investment rise in value and talk about it but don't cash out until almost the very end. Sounds to me more like Groupon is going down already, at least it's being talked down. I could be wrong but I'm wouldn't buy any shares even if I could.
- powera 15y agoJust saying "accounting is hard" doesn't mean anything about Groupon. Groupon's valuation is a bubble at best, and a scam at worst. Every accounting other than their own cherry-picked numbers supports this.
- omarchowdhury 15y ago"Note that original investors have cashed out more than $800 million, instead of using the money for operations."
- shareme 15y agoYou miss-understand the issues involved: 1. Groupon management chose the high risk style of customer acquisition with high upfront marketing costs. 2. Groupon management chose to use funding rounds to cash first-inline investors and employees out due to choice in 1. 3. Groupon than chose to hide that high risk in A SEc filing. I feel so strongly about the ethics here that I have refused to go to work fro any Lightbank Incubator start-up. Groupon ethically challenged operation. Similar to Enron, etc. It is not if they will get burned its when