4 ms·
If true, it makes the fact of not one but two large cities vaporized and thousands of civilians including many, many children made to slowly die in agony from r
by ck2 15y ago
If true, it makes the fact of not one but two large cities vaporized and thousands of civilians including many, many children made to slowly die in agony from radiation poisoning even more vile of an act, no?
- jessriedel 15y agoThe only thing that might change the morality of the bombing is if Truman's objective was actually to intimidate the Soviets (as was suggested but never convincingly argued in the article) rather than end the war (as is commonly assumed). Simply changing the reason why Japan surrendered shouldn't much change the morality of Truman's decision, since you're holding fixed what Truman believed. Analogously, most people think it's moral for a SWAT team to shoot and kill a hostage taker. The fact that the hostage taker was actually going to release the hostage anyway (unbeknownst to the SWAT team) if he wasn't shot doesn't really change the morality of the shooting. But really, 99% of the morality is decided by whether you think strategic bombing can ever be acceptable (either because you are a pure consequentialist, or because you subscribe to the Doctrine of Double Effect and accept that the bomb's actual target was the industrial base of the Japanese cities rather than their citizens). http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/double-effect/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/double-effect/
- sliverstorm 15y ago99% of the morality is decided by whether you think strategic bombing can ever be acceptable Perhaps this is why the bombings are so divisive even to this day- that dividing line is really pure opinion, and you know what they say about opinions...
- ck2 15y agoExcept one important fact - there was a large group of scientists who begged the US government to drop the bomb offshore Japan instead to demonstrate it's power. There's even a letter to prove this. President decided to ignore that and drop it on civilians first anyway. It's just military bloodlust. Remember half the US was practically foaming at the mouth to kill any Japanese at that point (we even had concentration camps for Japanese-Americans) so the mentality was there would be no repercussions, certainly no-one vocal enough to protest the morality.
- hasenj 15y agoWas it somehow "not so vile" before?
- emil0r 15y agoYou reap what you sow.
- cema 15y agoWell, that seals it for the Japanese. The question is, what about the Americans. Still controversial, after more than six decades. And I think will stay controversial for quite a while.
- emil0r 15y agoWhat about them? They were in a war and rightly more concerned about the lives of their own soldiers over those who wrongly attacked them, were fanatical in their defenses and were looking to drag the war on as long as possible for as favourable terms as possible in a cease-fire. Had the USA gone down the route of a land invasion it probably would've dragged on for several more months, possibly stretching into years. In the end you would've ended up with a peace treaty with the same war-mongering people in charge as before. Not a recipe for success.
- dicemoose 15y ago"In the end you would've ended up with a peace treaty with the same war-mongering people in charge as before." The Allies conditions for surrender by the Axis powers were for an unconditional surrender. All the Axis powers surrendered unconditionally regardless of whether they took an A-bomb or not.
- njharman 15y agoThose cities didn't get vaporized. Relatively small sections around impact did. As the article pointed out the allies had been fire bombing cites for awhile. Which does as much or more death and destruction. We should be agonizing over slaughtering civies to compel our enemies to surrender, A bombs or not.