3 ms·
I dunno, that doesn't seem convincing to me. Talking about parts of a mechanism in terms of "agency" is always a metaphor: A cogwheel or a transistor or a micr
by xg15 5y ago
I dunno, that doesn't seem convincing to me.
Talking about parts of a mechanism in terms of "agency" is always a metaphor: A cogwheel or a transistor or a microchip doesn't "know" either what it's supposed to do. However, what is the case is that those parts are designed specifically to emphasize or to suppress particular physical effects.
And this kind of "design" can be found in cells and proteins as well - not by any kind of designer but through evolution of the whole organism and storage in the DNA.
I also believe this is the fundamental difference between an ecosystem and an organism: In an ecosystem, each part evolves on its own and the whole system is simply the result of all interactions. In an organism, the evolution of individual cells is constrained. It's only the oragnism as a whole that evolves. This means that all the chaotic interactions between the different parts of the organism aren't completely random either, because all those parts have a common playbook.
The evolution of the organism has tuned the interactions between the different parts in such a way that they result in particular outcomes - which increase the fitness of the organism as a whole.
E.g., from the POV of a white blood cell, it really may just be a selfish predator, however the way it is attuned to particular kinds of "prey" and the way other molecules and up- or downregulate its aggressiveness is not simply by chance.
- vincentpants 5y agoI’m not entirely convinced that the line between organism and ecosystem is that clear cut. I think you’re just expressing an observation at a different octave et al.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoIt can be helpful to delineated systems in one way or another to attempt to clarify understanding and convey meaning. You’re right though, we need to be careful that those maps don’t get confused with reality and end up constraining thinking and meaning.