4 ms·
Unlimited PTO is always a passive-aggressive lie. Companies that start out the relationship with dishonesty are bad places to work.
by sneak 5y ago
Unlimited PTO is always a passive-aggressive lie.
Companies that start out the relationship with dishonesty are bad places to work.
- Florin_Andrei 5y agoYup. It becomes a negotiation, and the company by definition has orders of magnitude more negotiating power (arm-wrestling, etc) than you do. But hey, "freedom", yay!
- munk-a 5y agoThis is the unfortunate truth of a lot of US labour laws and why I prefer it up here in Canada. I know with certainty that my coworkers (even university coops!) have access to good healthcare and have provincially mandated vacation time. I work hard in my position and carry a fair amount of responsibility that I've accrued over the years - but I don't want any of my coworkers, no matter how junior and no matter how short their stay at this company may be, to struggle to live a healthy life.
- chemeng 5y agoIt's a cost savings measure for CA companies to avoid having to hold employee's earned vacation hours as a liability to be paid out if they are unused when the employee separates. This is also why they cannot set a minimum, as that would indicate an amount of earned vacation per year. To be clear, this is still very disingenuous and I believe companies should stop the practice.
- WorldMaker 5y agoIt is a loophole in labor laws that CA's legislature especially should close because it is against the spirit/intent of the laws that vacation time should be an asset owed to the employee as part of total compensation, not a whim to be managed (removed without recompense) by the employer.
- MattGaiser 5y agoThere are some companies where it seems legitimate, especially larger ones. I hear that at Indeed for example it is very legitimate. The problem in smaller ones is not so much that it is a deliberate lie, but rather a promise the business cannot keep as the bus factor for lots of roles is 1.
- sneak 5y agoIt's not legitimate, otherwise you'd take 100% paid time off, get a second job, and collect two paychecks in perpetuity. It's not unlimited. It's never unlimited. It's always a lie.
- MattGaiser 5y agoFair. I agree that it is not truly unlimited.
- drstewart 5y ago>It's not legitimate, otherwise you'd take 100% paid time off, get a second job, and collect two paychecks in perpetuity. This is not a great argument. Unlimited just means there isn't a pre-defined limit, not that every amount has to be approved. Do you think there's unlimited amounts of money in the world? If yes, then by definition it's worthless (also, can I have a trillion dollars an hour?). If no, then what's the maximum amount of money?
- sneak 5y ago> Unlimited just means there isn't a pre-defined limit, not that every amount has to be approved. Do you work for my ISP's marketing department?
- RHSeeger 5y agoThen it's not unlimited, it's flexible.
- tomcorrigan 5y agoSo you mean 'no defined limit but definitely not unlimited' or do you mean 'unlimited except with the following limitations'? You don't have a great argument.
- acidbaseextract 5y agoI am a small business owner with unlimited PTO. It's not a passive aggressive lie. I want people to take time off. I just can't have large outstanding liabilities associated with accrued PTO.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hmottestad 5y agoDo employees take out more than the regular 5 weeks a year that most people in Europe do?
- withinboredom 5y agoI worked somewhere where this was the case. A guy went on a two week vacation and called in every two weeks to extend it: for four months. Genius. After that, it was still unlimited, but after three weeks, it was unpaid.
- munk-a 5y agoCan't you just force vacation time payout annually to avoid large liabilities? I've worked in places like that and it's usually received pretty well - there isn't any expectation of accruing half a year of vacation over several years of employment anymore - at least not in younger (under forty) folks.
- ghaff 5y agoAny company I've worked at with an accrual vacation system has typically had an accrual max, i.e. your vacation doesn't go away but you stop accumulating more when it hits the cap which is usually something like 1.5x annual accrual.
- munk-a 5y agoThat's a good way to avoid the situation where employees need to take vacations as unpaid time in january but they still end up hitting the same issue in June (or whenever the cap kicks in). So if you accrued up to the max at one of these places would the additional time you would accrue just get immediately paid out? Or was no vacation time earned?
- yupper32 5y agoThe people I know with "Unlimited" PTO all take more than my 5 weeks of limited PTO. Lie or not, it's still better.
- RHSeeger 5y ago> it's still better. It _can_ still be better. Or it can be worse, as in the OP's situation.
- yupper32 5y agoSo... bad companies are going to be bad companies. Unlimited PTO has nothing to do with it.
- mrtweetyhack 5y agoUnlimited PTO are used to sucker people into the job
- lghh 5y agoI have unlimited PTO and have for quite a while and love it. We are encouraged to take off at least 5 days a quarter / 20 days a year in addition to our holidays (which are flexible given culture, personal preference, etc). We don't count sick days or appointment time towards that. We can take off more, and frequently do, we just have to tell someone we're doing it. We frequently are put on "nicely forced" vacations if our manager notices we have not taken off in a while. You'll usually get a message from your manager like "hey, schedule some time off in the next month, it's been a bit since you've been off". This doesn't include parental leave as well, which is pretty solid compared to other places I've been.