4 ms·
I watched a video the other day of a geologist talking about the fact that the hardest thing she had to deal with when working in Antarctica was the way her the
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I watched a video the other day of a geologist talking about the fact that the hardest thing she had to deal with when working in Antarctica was the way her thesis advisor acted. And since she needed a letter from him to proceed then his threat of "you'll never work in science again" had some basis in reality.
She talked about how deeply it impacted her but that she only reported when her 3 year old daughter said she wanted to be a scientist like her.
It did make me wonder about how we could restructure academia/society so that random individuals don't have so much power over other people. It seems like a recipe for disaster.
I wonder if this is where the seniority thing that people complain about in unions came from. If there's some subjective element then you've basically given control of your whole life over to the person who makes the decision.
edit: one idea, randomisation. If you give the person in power the ability to choose X people, but then the eventual winner is picked in some documented and fair manner from that list, then that may reduce their leverage.
- mlazos 5y agoI’ve noticed this is very prevalent in industries and academia where there are very few spots with oceans of people trying to “make it” into said spots. For example, academia is absolutely insane how insular it is. The communities of experts in fields is so small, and mainly due to tradition in most cases professors pretty much dictate who succeeds because the communities and available positions are so small. Surprise surprise, after decades of this cutthroat rat race in academia, there are many assholes in power. Rinse and repeat for Condé Nast (old school media (newspapers, magazines) were exactly this gate keeping BS. Hollywood!! (Harvey Weinstein and co) and honestly we are starting to hear about it with startups and VC. I’m sure this is everywhere, but especially in these areas/industries where there are a few kingmakers and swathes of people willing to do anything to get ahead, the kingmakers take advantage of their power.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThe parallels we see in abusers across cultures and institutions likely indicates that this is a dark face of human behavior that needs extreme mitigation strategies (there are documented cases in essentially every institution with a power structure). There are a lot of ways forward that will improve the lives of children, the biggest hurdle is getting adults to listen and then implement.
- tru3_power 5y agoMy take on this is we need to raise people to know that it’s OK to question authority.
- sangnoir 5y agoSwinging back to the article in question - this has devastating results on the victims when the questions are ignored by others in authority. So in addition to questioning authority, those in authority also need to be held accountable for their actions.
- kongin 5y ago>It did make me wonder about how we could restructure academia/society so that random individuals don't have so much power over other people. It seems like a recipe for disaster. Never work in a job you're not prepared to quit. The people who talk about their harrowing experiences have had a lot of less harrowing experiences that should have made them quit much earlier if they weren't living in a fairy tale. I saw it first hand when the head of my school, a woman, started berating me for trying to get into a more 'prestigious' program than the one I was in at the time. The whole meeting was so weird I started asking around for career prospects of high energy physics - two months later I dropped out and moved to be a quant and saved myself a wasted 20s.
- smt88 5y agoWow, this is an awful take. > Never work in a job you're not prepared to quit. Most humans working today can't quit their job without another job already lined up. Some people (like those in the later stages of their PhD) can't quit at all. They would end up losing potentially years of progress. > I saw it first hand when the head of my school, a woman, started berating me for trying to get into a more 'prestigious' program than the one I was in at the time. The whole meeting was so weird I started asking around for career prospects of high energy physics - two months later I dropped out and moved to be a quant and saved myself a wasted 20s. This situation has absolutely nothing to do with what you were responding to. Changing career tracks in your early 20s isn't a big deal if you have fungible skills that are in high demand. Not everyone is in their early 20s or has high-demand skills, and that doesn't mean it's suddenly their fault that they're being abused. Your single anecdote where you were a brave hero who wasn't "living in a fairy tale" doesn't give you some special insight or authority to tell other people they're stupid for trying to push through the early stages of a bad situation. No one knows whether or not it'll get worse or how long it will last. They do know there will be potentially severe financial and career consequences for leaving.
- kongin 5y ago>Most humans working today can't quit their job without another job already lined up. Some people (like those in the later stages of their PhD) can't quit at all. They would end up losing potentially years of progress. I was in the later stages of my PhD. It was rather easy once I got over my ego. >This situation has absolutely nothing to do with what you were responding to. Changing career tracks in your early 20s isn't a big deal if you have fungible skills that are in high demand. Not everyone is in their early 20s or has high-demand skills, and that doesn't mean it's suddenly their fault that they're being abused. There are plenty of unskilled jobs you can move to and you'd be no worse off than the 50% of Americans who work in them. >Your single anecdote where you were a brave hero who wasn't "living in a fairy tale" doesn't give you some special insight or authority to tell other people they're stupid for trying to push through the early stages of a bad situation. No one knows whether or not it'll get worse or how long it will last. They do know there will be potentially severe financial and career consequences for leaving. You sound extremely defensive, may I suggest you objectively review your situation?
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> It did make me wonder about how we could restructure academia/society so that random individuals don't have so much power over other people. It seems like a recipe for disaster. Transparency. People in power intent on abusing it can only be disincentivized by the possibility of being outed. Hence why I think it should be legal to record any audio you are privy to. There are far too many places with all party consent laws about recording audio, which only serve to help those with power take advantage of those without power.
- yhoneycomb 5y agoMedical residency for newly graduated medical doctors is another academic training program where abuse runs rampant. Basically, the residency program owns you for at least 3 years (often more) and the only protection you have is that you can’t work over 80 hours per week averaged over a 4 week period (gee, thanks). The issue is that people are afraid to report their hours accurately because if they do the program director will meet with them and ask, “sooo it seems like you’re not as efficient as the other residents [who are all lying to evade the ire of higher-ups]. You really need to work on that, or else you might need to be held back or even dismissed.” If you’re dismissed, you can’t work as a doctor. No one will hire a doctor without residency training. You’re completely screwed. There was a resident anesthesiologist at the University of New Mexico who was allegedly raped by her boss. She reported it to the program and was dismissed. She later settled a lawsuit for only 800k, essentially two years worth of salary as an attending (fully-trained) anesthesiologist and she likely only saw less than 100 or 200k of that after lawyers fees, taxes, and paying off her medical school loans (mine are 350k, and that’s only because COVID has stopped the 7% compounded interest rate). She now teaches anatomy at a community college because no one will accept her into their residency program. And then people wonder why many doctors lack empathy. It’s hard to have empathy when you’ve been essentially tortured for years until your spirit has broken. Hurt people hurt people.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> If you’re dismissed, you can’t work as a doctor. No one will hire a doctor without residency training. You’re completely screwed. I thought you needed to complete residency to get a license to practice as a doctor (reimbursable by CMS). Hence, of course no employer will hire you as a doctor because they would not get paid for your work.
- yhoneycomb 5y agoThat sounds right. Same end result either way.
- fabian2k 5y agoThis dynamic exists in pretty much every situation where you can't switch or move somewhere else without losing your progress or suffering other significant penalties. If you're doing your PhD, you can't really switch to another supervisor in most cases without almost starting over. Additionally in small fields it could really hurt to make an influential enemy. This can happen in regular jobs if you are desperate to keep it, e.g. you have no real financial buffer and not many alternative jobs in the area. But in many cases it's a lot easier to just switch to somewhere else, which reduces these kinds of power imbalances.
- valarauko 5y ago> It did make me wonder about how we could restructure academia/society so that random individuals don't have so much power over other people. It seems like a recipe for disaster. As someone working my way through (and hopefully out of) academia, the issue here is that the thesis advisor is not some random individual. Yes, even under favorable conditions the circumstances are ripe for abuse. Unfortunately I'm not sure what the solution would be.
- npteljes 5y agoIn a science fiction novel I read, the power problem was said to be solved with a hierarchy that was not acyclic, so nobody was another's absolute superior. I don't think this would work in reality though.