7 ms·
> He suggested the company could expand to “annotate the world,” including “poetry, literature, the Bible, political speeches, legal texts, science papers.” In
by OJFord 5y ago
> He suggested the company could expand to “annotate the world,” including “poetry, literature, the Bible, political speeches, legal texts, science papers.” In fact, it had trouble expanding beyond its core group of music fans.
That sounds great to me, anybody know what caused so much trouble? Looking at genius.com now it's not even trying, homepage is all about music.
- hobofan 5y agoIt's been some time, but as I roughly recall it: - Very few original content on the platform (and a lot of relevant content is already old and exists elsewhere), and trying to get that content on the platform is a huge copyright minefield. - If you as a website owner wanted to allow your users to annotate your content, you had to include their script snippet to the website. I wouldn't be suprised if a brower extension based method would have been better for bootstrapping that side of the business.
- relaxatorium 5y agoIf I remember correctly, their method for “annotate the world” was less expand the types of content on genius.com and more some sort of extension or standard for slapping their annotations onto other people’s sites which never really took off and also pissed people off.
- bambax 5y agoThe founders had a reputation for being dickish. At some point they got into trouble for dubious SEO tactics that got them delisted from the Google index. More controversially, they were able to unfuck themselves by reaching out to Google executives, while so many other companies are at the mercy of Google with no recourse.
- DeBraid 5y agoThe drama with Google has to be mentioned as major part of their company history. They also had a famous fight with heroku https://genius.com/James-somers-herokus-ugly-secret-annotated https://genius.com/James-somers-herokus-ugly-secret-annotate...
- jayzalowitz 5y agoIf you are capable of making this post, you are capable of self hosting rails on something closer to the metal.
- nomilk 5y agoGenius's investigation and analysis of Heroku's load balancing claims vs their actual practices was anything but "dickish", and it wasn't a "fight". They produced an intelligent, thorough, and fair exposè of poor engineering practices by Heroku which were otherwise not documented (or worse, misleadingly documented), and which also benefited Heroku financially, since users would have to purchase many more dynos to get the expected performance - up to 50 times more if I recall correctly. Genius didn't have to share any of their analysis. They could have simply shown it to Heroku and probably received a bunch of "hush" benefits to forget about the whole thing. The fact they bothered to polish it and open source it allowed others to benefit from their work and meant that even 8 years' later, someone like me can better plan hosting requirements and avoid falling into the trap they did. Yes, Heroku's load balancing works the same way to this day, resulting in much higher costs to medium-large apps as well as huge degradations to end user experience as some users will randomly be routed to dynos with long queues despite others being completely idle! This is a huge waste of energy and bad for the environment too. As a heavy Heroku user, I'm incredibly grateful for Genius's work on this issue!
- glenngillen 5y agoThat’s one interpretation of the events, motivations, and hypothetical alternative situations. Or it’s simply that Heroku didn’t provide customers great visibility into a the issue at hand, that the best-in-class at the time 3rd party add-on that gave that visibility was misleading, and that architectural changes required to support a broader set of languages in a more distributed fashion introduced a change in behaviour that was not documented. The engineering best practice continues to be the same, which is why it is unchanged 8 years later: push long-running requests into an async flow. It’s both more scalable and more durable.
- 5y ago
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoI love the idea of "annotating everything" / the web. A browser extension or something would liberate people from these walled social media gardens of interacting. Just not attractive and a hard sell. I remember seeing a cringy interview of the founders. Candidly, I'm not surprised they couldn't convert their idea and make it happen with something bigger. Who knows though they did raise the cash. I still think there is room here though.
- bambax 5y agoGoogle created Sidewiki [0] in 2009 and killed it two years later. It was based on a browser extension. There have been many other initiatives, some listed here [1]; Wikalong was interesting but riddled with spam. Maybe a personal system (not shared) would help prevent content abuse? But then it would probably offer too little value to really take off. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Sidewiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Sidewiki [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_annotation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_annotation
- cxr 5y agoHypothesis is going strong. They have smart people working on it, it's fully open source with open APIs and data available over anonymous RSS, the culture is nothing like rap/bro culture, and the founder is independently wealthy from winning the startup lottery in a past life and seems to be running the thing as a passion project no matter how much it makes. (Their main commercial play right now is selling higher ed. on the idea of using Hypothes.is for scholarly criticism.) See "Notes for an Annotation SDK" from a couple weeks ago <https://blog.jonudell.net/2021/09/03/notes-for-an-annotation-sdk/ https://blog.jonudell.net/2021/09/03/notes-for-an-annotation...>
- setgree 5y agoLike 8 years ago, I began annotating a Cormac McCarthy novel on Genius, and I quickly got a DM from a site admin who offered me a “Poetry Genius editor” position — tons of free karma and the ability to make edits without review — and encouraged me to keep writing. I didn’t pursue it very far and a few years later, I got another DM from a different admin saying that they were reducing the number of editors and: > While reviewing your stuff, I noticed that you’ve got some really high quality work, but there are a few areas that could use a bit of improvement. Don’t worry, this doesn’t mean you’re guaranteed to be de-editored, it just means we need to work together on improving your annotations/acceptances That sounded like work, so I declined :) And thus was my editorship revoked. I am going to guess that they had trouble ever getting a volunteer-editor model to stick. P.S. the original DM thread offering me an editor position contains this gem: > The deal with usage is this. We of course want to work on as much stuff in public domain (we have A LOT up there now). But if a newer text is elsewhere on the web we feel like it’s fair game. Translation: if someone else shares content illegally, we can too P.P.S. I think their SEO shenanigans [0) set them back a lot. Genius results still don’t come up very high when I google lyrics sometimes. [0] https://techcrunch.com/2013/12/25/google-rap-genius/amp/ https://techcrunch.com/2013/12/25/google-rap-genius/amp/
- TuringNYC 5y agoCurious why bands dont enter their own lyrics? Isnt this a no-brainer for bands to do, so their lyrics are not mangled in the crowd-sourcing process? Or do they want people to struggle and settle upon the lyrics collectively as part of the entertainment process?
- OJFord 5y agoTangentially, it reminds me that probably the best book I ever I read, taken in the context of the time/mathematical ability in my life, was The Annotated Turing (Charles Petzold) - a sort of walk-through of and background to Turing's On Computable Numbers with an Application to the Entscheidungsproblem. It's surely the most 'sci' of any 'pop sci' I'm aware of, taking the reader through the actual paper but just really explaining it all step by step at a level comprehensible to someone without or before any undergrad CS or mathematics. I'd thoroughly recommend it to (or as a gift for) any CS-interested teenager in your life.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> That sounds great to me, anybody know what caused so much trouble? They are competing with Wikipedia?
- OJFord 5y agoAre they? I can't go to Wikipedia for explanation of 'poetry, literature, [...] political speeches, legal texts, science papers' aside from really famous and specific examples (such as 'the Bible' which I omitted in quoting). Even the entry 'On Computable Numbers[ with an application to the Entscheidungsproblem]' for example, redirects to its entry in a list. [0] where the entire annotation, as it were, is: > Description: This article set the limits of computer science. It defined the Turing Machine, a model for all computations. On the other hand, it proved the undecidability of the halting problem and Entscheidungsproblem and by doing so found the limits of possible computation. As I alluded to in a sibling comment to yours, [1] the potential as I see it would be something more like (a less thorough version of) Petzold's The Annotated Turing - line by line annotations of the actual paper, explaining anything non-trivial the reader might want to hover-over. I'd love to read more academic output, and I honestly think I would if there were an easier Genius/Petzold-style way to be taught the bits I'm missing as I work through it. To my regret I didn't stay for a PhD; I don't have a supervisor to nag or whom who can guide me through easy to harder to grok works. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_important_publications_in_theoretical_computer_science#On_computable_numbers,_with_an_application_to_the_Entscheidungsproblem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_important_publications... [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28551572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28551572
- selimthegrim 5y agoFermat’s Library? Arxiv vanity?
- TuringNYC 5y ago> anybody know what caused so much trouble? Removing the co-founder, who had so much passion for the business?
- mbesto 5y agoGenius's lack of execution is precisely the embodiment of the SV trope of bro culture: - Grandiose visions of product brilliance ("we're changing the world" = "we want to annotate it all") - Flashy "bro culture" https://venturebeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/rap-genius.jpg?fit=655%2C472&strip=all https://venturebeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/rap-geniu... - Breaking the "rules" and not getting penalized for it (Google reverted its penalty): https://techcrunch.com/2013/12/25/google-rap-genius/ https://techcrunch.com/2013/12/25/google-rap-genius/ I rarely want companies to fail (I'm very critical of start-ups, but generally am happy when good people succeed), but it's hard for me to root for company that operates like this.
- throwdecro 5y agoI definitely wanted them to fail, and I'm relieved that they did. If they'd succeeded there might have been an onslaught of additional clowns you'd have to filter out when looking for work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mmmpop 5y agoI agree, I never liked how they presented themselves. I can't help but associate the "culture" of the founders with that of the organization, but that may not always be fair.
- peterthehacker 5y agoIt sounds like a Herculean marketing effort to rebrand from rap music to all music then to sophisticated literature. Those markets are completely different. Then of course theres the copyright issues.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SquishyPanda23 5y agoLyric interpretations was already an existing market, but most implementations weren't great. Genius built a nicer interface that allowed them to take that market. For everything else they'd have to create a market from nowhere. And people would have to be willing to donate their time and content to Genius to make it work.