3 ms·
> The forebears of nearly two-thirds of India’s Catholics are Dalits who converted to escape stigma. Yet among four cardinals and 31 archbishops, only two are o
by OJFord 5y ago
> The forebears of nearly two-thirds of India’s Catholics are Dalits who converted to escape stigma. Yet among four cardinals and 31 archbishops, only two are of Dalit origin.
(Rest of it aside) that specifically doesn't seem necessarily that bad? If many of them aren't exactly devout Catholics ('converted to escape') then it seems reasonable they wouldn't (perhaps even want to!) reach high office. And there's perhaps a different stigma surrounding converts anyway, that's nothing specific to what they converted from or their status within it.
- rg111 5y agoWhat you say makes sense. But some of these people are really poor. Among the "racist" people in the US, many are actually "classist". That also runs high in Indian society. In my experience Christians are much more forward thinking and secular than other minorities in India. They live peacefully and blend very well with the Hindus. Even most of their names, outside of Goa, Mumbai, etc., are derived from Sanskrit, Tamil, Bengali roots depending on the region. A lot of Indian Christians will have only one name, i.e. middle name or first name identifying their Christian identity. Sometimes they often just ommit the Christian part except in official documents. Anyway, this is a good sign totally as you say, but that is true in prosperous regions and/or households. For backward regions and poor families, I am not sure if people will even let them hold religious offices. Btw, even Christians can claim backward castes benefits if their ancestors happened to belong to a so called lower caste when they were not Christians.
- foolinaround 5y ago> In my experience Christians are much more forward thinking and secular than other minorities in India. Sadly, not by much. Indian Christians have adopted many of the vices of the West ( the rates of divorce among Indian Christians are higher than Indians), but in terms of a broader outlook, I have seen this only in the sub-category of those living in big cities, and predominantly english-speaking and educated. The Christians in rural areas continue to hold on to caste, despite all efforts. In some ways, the Church structures themselves are casteist, and bar people from being part of it.
- foolinaround 5y agoIn India, if one converts to a Christian, one is supposed to 'escaped' the caste system, and therefore loses all the benefits of affirmation action. This is especially true of non-Dalits but still lower castes. The reality however is that the person is still shunned in their tight social circles. So, for such individuals (and I know personally of many) -- they do not change their names, in fact they do not even marry by Christian traditions publicly because they may get outed. There really is no number of how many such 'secret Christians' are there, but I would guess this number will be in the lakhs...