4 ms·
It certainly qualifies as "software." What possible definition of "software" would exclude a web application? Obviously, literally any software could be identi
by baddox 15y ago
It certainly qualifies as "software." What possible definition of "software" would exclude a web application?
Obviously, literally any software could be identically implemented in any language. Lines of code don't really matter, but I strongly expect that the Arc code of HN is much more concise than an implementation in php/asp/python/perl would be, even if you used a web framework. PG prides himself in the conciseness of the HN code, and Arc seems to lend itself to concise implementations of web apps.
As for maintainability and bug proneness, both depend more on the programmer(s) than the language.
- thiefmaster 15y ago> It certainly qualifies as "software." What possible definition of "software" would exclude a web application? My point was that it doesn't do heavy algorithm lifting, processing etc. It's not a phong shading ray tracer or anything. It's moving data around, storing it and displaying it. It's mostly plumbing work - getting data from one place to another.
- dagw 15y agoI'm sure I could write a simple phong shading ray tracer faster than I could build a copy of this web site. Re-implementing a well known and well understood algorithm is easy, making a working and popular application that people enjoy using is hard
- zck 15y agoIn pg's ANSI Common Lisp, he defines a ray tracer in one page of code, creates all the necessary functions for spheres in another page, then inserts 28 spheres and prints out the world in a dozen lines of code. There's part of a page of utility functions, like creating a point structure. You can examine the code here: http://lib.store.yahoo.net/lib/paulgraham/acl2.lisp http://lib.store.yahoo.net/lib/paulgraham/acl2.lisp . Search for the first instance of "surface".
- baddox 15y agoI don't know anything about ray tracers, but if it's an algorithm, then it's "mostly plumbing work" in the same way you say a web application is. The beauty of the world we live in is that you can compute anything that can be computed with an absurdly small set of basic operations.