6 ms·
Multi-year chart of lumber prices puts some of these "skyrocketing" and "cratering" headlines in perspective: https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lumber http
by xnx 5y ago
Multi-year chart of lumber prices puts some of these "skyrocketing" and "cratering" headlines in perspective: https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lumber https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lumber
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI like the chart, but it's exactly what the article indicated, no? Article indicated It went up to 3 times the price and is now down to pre rocket prices. Charts seem to agree?
- da_chicken 5y agoBecause sometimes "skyrocketing" means going 1% over the average annual high, or "cratering" going 2% below widely published analyst forecasting. In other words, the media is often radically hyperbolic to get clicks and ad views. So much so that when they use the same adjectives correctly they don't carry any weight anymore. They're the boy who cried wolf.
- arthurcolle 5y agoAverage annual high (I'm assuming you're using the stock price daily high from a multi-year set of highs from its daily OHLC bars as the 'high' here) is a poor metric to evaluate whether or not a company is doing well. Low beta stocks usually don't really outperform so I mean you need to just optimize for low correlation, high relative outperformance vs. a sector wide index or something. I just don't think the random numbers you asserted are real at all - this would be something that one would need to test. Anyone getting their 'market moving news' from BusinessInsider/financial news sites is doing it wrong.
- da_chicken 5y agoThe entire point was that the metrics I chose were bad. Furthermore they were such minor differences that even if they weren't bad they still wouldn't be relevant. They were intended to be comically useless. It means that the hypothetical author of the article didn't have any idea what they're reporting, which is exactly what I was trying to express. The authors rely on the readers' ignorance and the way many people reflexively accept numeric data as true, pertinent, and sufficient evidence of any claim.
- arthurcolle 5y agoSorry about that - just saw the article and immediately started hyperventilating/wanted to vent as a child comment with someone that also seemed to 'get it' haha... cheers
- scottLobster 5y agoI wouldn't define "returning to historic norms" as "cratering". Would you define a plane landing smoothly on a runway, even after a steep dive, as "cratering" the runway?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI guess it depends but to me cratering is more about slope of the curve than its final destination. So I can see a plane barreling or diving or catering down, before pulling up on the runway...
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoI don’t understand your comment and scare quotes, do you think a quadrupling in price of a commodity is not skyrocketing? That’s a cool website thank you for sharing it.
- hoppyhoppy2 5y agoPerhaps they were just quotation marks rather than scare quotes and they genuinely wanted to show how wild the price fluctuations have been. Cynicism abounds on the internet, but people are still sometimes genuine.
- xnx 5y agoThanks. I'm legitimately quoting, but also prefer use of more specific terms like "tripled" or "fives times more expensive" etc. than common dramatic headlines words like "crushed", "slammed", "blasted", "surged".
- chejazi 5y agoDon't forget "soared" and "plunged", used practically any day the market moves more than a hair.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoIt's interesting to pay attention to the verbs chosen to describe things done or said by politicians
- exporectomy 5y agoYep. One of the ways reporters mislead people while remaining factually correct. Then they blame factually incorrect news as destroying society while they're just doing the same thing more tactfully.
- 5y ago
- fouc 5y agoThe 25Y chart looks interesting, a reversion to the mean. Prices finally came back to the normal range.
- godelski 5y agoTo me what is interesting is comparing to other commodities. For Iron you see a similar pattern to lumber. Copper and steel boombed but are only starting to turn now. Is there a lag between raw materials and more refined materials? Silver and gold similarly, though gold has fallen harder. I'm guessing because of all the doomers that buy gold when the economy dips. I don't know how to analyze wheat. And crude oil just flash crashed. Like literal flash crash. I wonder if anyone knows the reasoning behind these different patterns.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bcrosby95 5y agoNote that you can't just cut down a tree and make lumber out of it. You have to dry it out first, which, afaik can take a long time. I don't know about the other stuff though.
- rfrey 5y agoMost construction lumber is kiln dried in less than five weeks.
- philistine 5y agoFive weeks is a fucking long time !
- rfrey 5y agoYeah, somebody should really teach them about scrum. XTreme sawmilling.
- gotorazor 5y agoThere isn't that much excess kilns to dry lumber. They have to be of a certain standard -- especially if they are graded.
- 5y ago
- OneLeggedCat 5y agoPrices have NEVER been this low since like, June of last year.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- willvarfar 5y agoThat's a very cool site! When I click on the 25Y and 'all' views, it definitely looks like a hockey stick. Ergo the popular narrative of lumber prices has been accurate.
- 3minus1 5y agoI just want to express appreciation for your comment. I don't know why the news article wouldn't include a chart like this, but I'm glad you posted it.