4 ms·
This is more interesting (Instagram response to WSJ, linked to in the article): https://about.instagram.com/blog/announcements/using-research-to-improve-your-ex
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
This is more interesting (Instagram response to WSJ, linked to in the article): https://about.instagram.com/blog/announcements/using-research-to-improve-your-experience https://about.instagram.com/blog/announcements/using-researc...
"We're increasingly focused on addressing negative social comparison and negative body image. One idea we think has promise is finding opportunities to jump in if we see people dwelling on certain types of content."
"From our research, we're starting to understand the types of content some people feel may contribute to negative social comparison, and we're exploring ways to prompt them to look at different topics if they're repeatedly looking at this type of content."
Wow, talk about "Big Brother".
Facebook/Instagram monitors everything the user looks at, how many times and for how long, and now they will "jump in" and alert the user.
"We're watching you and we think you should look at something else."
Meanwhile the whole "business model" of Instgram/Facebook is online advertising.
Advertising, e.g., in print, is what created these "negative body image" problems in the first place!
As they say, in the world of computers, what is old is new again. Originality is rare.
Big Tech relies on the same tired, old consumerism ideas, except it operates over the internet.
The only thing "futuristic" is the surveillance. Its nothing less than incredible what young people today are tolerating. Are they studying the psychological affects of surveillance on young people.
- mc32 5y agoYeah. As if it's not obvious "engagement" and "influencers" aren't the real problem, no instead, it's "huh, some people actually fall for the ads (body image)". Stop promoting trash and see the problem go away --but so will their main cash cow. That might color their decision-making a bit.
- Tarsul 5y agoI'd like to think that by "jumping in" they mean that they change what kind of content the algorithms shows their users... however, I'd guess that no such self-regulation could ever suffice (esp. because it would always be less important than ad money in internal metrics).
- OJFord 5y agoI expect so too, and was going to say the same, but it's not actually that different (to a pop-up, or message, or whatever invasive 'jump-in' alternative) is it? It just means most people won't know about it.
- esperent 5y agoThere's no difference, fundamentally, between displaying a popup to suggest looking at different material, and automatically showing different material. Both are equally creepy - actually, doing it automatically is more creepy. At least a popup let's the user know they're being spied on.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"We're cautiously optimistic that these nudges will help point people towards content that inspires and uplifts them, and to a larger extent, will shift the part of Instagram's culture that focuses on how people look." The term "nudge" could have multiple meanings. For example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_(instant_messaging) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_(instant_messaging) or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_theory In either case, given the modus operandi of a "tech" company, its an encroachment on free will. An subversive attempt to influence decision-making deisgned to fly under the radar. "Tech" companies already do this with their so-called "dark patterns", making choices confusing or removing viable choices altogether. There is nothing new here in this "rebuttal" from Instagram, except perhaps a new "justification" (a parallel construction) they can cite as to why they corraled a user to look at something (favorable to Instagrams 100% ad-dependent business) when the user actually wanted to look at something else. Of course, Instagram could provide users with this "nudge" feature as an option (like HN has noprocrast), but we all know they wont. That is not a choice they want the user to have. The "business" of these companies is to show advertising to users. They are middlemen. Watching and plotting.
- wwweston 5y ago> In either case, given the modus operandi of a "tech" company, its an encroachment on free will. Given the nature of every medium ever includes some focus inherent in what creators make and curators highlight/disseminate, this seems like a bit of an overstatement. The decisions of a film studio, book author, or magazine editor aren't an encroachment on my free will, I can always tune out and look for something else. Heck with social media, no matter how it may nudge via the feed. I'm usually free to choose my own walk through individual profiles, groups, and pages on a scale that would have been hard to really understand a half century ago. If there is one thing that is not our problem, it's being nudged/herded into an oversmall number of options.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoDisagree with this assessment. Tech companies are able to manipulate the audience for someone else's content "on a scale that would have been hard to really understand a half century ago." Films, books and magazines are not interactive media. Computers force their users to provide input, much more input than a channel to a TV tuner. As developers, it is definitely our problem because we can control that input. We can require input to suit our needs over the user's. We can monitor the user's interaction. We can easily redirect the user to locations he never intentionally specified he want to go. The TV tuning dial, the buttons on a TV remote or a TV's onscreen menu were more or less fixed. These could not be continually manipulated to optimise for the advertiser. No redirection. There was no software developer who was paid to manipulate, positioned between a film and a viewer in a theater, or between a reader and a physical book, or between a reader and a printed magazine. Yes, people have more options thanks to computers, but theres now a middle layer of manipulation between people and the media they are consuming.
- curryst 5y agoI'm not a fan of Facebook, but it's not a bad idea. I think Facebook/Instagram being present is poisoning the well on what might be a good idea. In a different context, you could use a similar tech to suggest opposing viewpoints. "We noticed you've been watching a lot of flat earth documentaries. Why don't you take a look at the other side of the argument?". Or maybe on Reddit "We noticed a lot of the threads you've been viewing are overly hostile. Why not relax for a little bit over on /r/chillmusicandducks?" I also wouldn't mind a system like that on days that something terrible has happened. The stuff that happened in Kabul was terrible, but I don't think I would've minded a nudge to go remind myself that there are happy things too. It's not like they weren't already collecting info on what you look and for how long anyways. I don't really see a change in privacy here (it was abysmal to being with), just Facebook leveraging its user data to maybe actually help users for once. I give it 3 months until they realize it impacts engagement numbers and replace it with a toothless version that doesn't help, but also doesn't impact engagement.