4 ms·
Not clear whether this is even illegal, though. As long as they refer to existing objects, they're not securities, and since they're all different, they're not
by Animats 5y ago
Not clear whether this is even illegal, though. As long as they refer to existing objects, they're not securities, and since they're all different, they're not commodities. So they escape both SEC and CFTC regulation in the US. (The UK's Financial Conduct Authority, though...) That's the whole point of NFTs.
In 2019-2020, the SEC cracked down on Initial Coin Offerings. They grandfathered in the early coins, and shut down some out and out scams. Then the SEC started sending out letters, "explain to us why your ICO isn't a security offering requiring registration as an IPO". Suddenly there was a huge drop in ICOs.
So then came NFTs, which looked like they were going to evade regulation. Then some of the NFT issuers started making NFTs which looked like IPOs. Selling land in virtual worlds that don't exist yet, for example. That's a no-no. That passes the Howey Test - value paid into a common enterprise, with the expectation of future gains, to be derived from the efforts of others. That's the definition of an investment in the US. If the value of an NFT depends on the future efforts of the organization involved with the NFT, it's a security.
That doesn't quite seem to be the case here, though. It's legal, and fairly common, for an art dealer to front-run artworks or have shill buyers. You're supposed to know what the art is worth.
Selling NFTs in bulk, though, might start to look like a security for regulation purposes. Selling fractional shares in NFTs definitely is. The SEC is working on a guidance memo. If you're starting up an NFT, you definitely need some time with a securities lawyer. Remember, the whole point of most NFTs is to try to evade securities regulation. That comes with serious legal risks.
[1] https://www.howeycoins.com https://www.howeycoins.com
- Y_Y 5y agoWhat does "refer to existing objects" mean? Are these any better than baseball cards or top trumps?
- vkou 5y agoI don't think 'refer to existing objects' is the meaningful bit, here. You can print and sell and trade and auction baseball cards of players that don't exist, and they'll still be regulated the same way as baseball cards of players who do. (Which is to say, not at all.) I think the meaningful bit is whether or not an NFT is a baseball card, or ownership of... Some yet to be generated value, somehow derived from a baseball card. The latter is obviously a security, the former is, to my layman eyes, probably not. Continuing on this train of thought, it should be worth noting that useless things (Ownership of a baseball cards) are not regulated, but useful things (Ownership of a stake in the value generated by a baseball card) are regulated. It makes sense, in a perverse way - if someone wants to spend their money on a useless thing, that's on them. If someone wants to spend their money on a useful thing, then, well, the buyer should expect some assurance that they are not being completely lied to and swindled. (Which is why the SEC regulates securities markets, and not art auctions.)
- space_rock 5y agoCan eBay pump up the price of it's own items with fake trading bots? No that's fraud. There are laws around auctions and trading. I'm guessing it's illegal
- unclebucknasty 5y agoThe key here is disclosure. If eBay was transparent with its bot activity, then it may be legal.
- space_rock 5y agoNot transparent and market manipulation change the situation entirely. And many govt agree and will happily put you in prison
- npteljes 5y ago>Not clear whether this is even illegal, though. I think it's not, and I wager this is what's attractive about crypto for these people. All the old tricks are new again, because crypto kinda works like how currencies, exchanges etc work, but the regulation is few and far between yet.