4 ms·
Their summary: - Founders banished - Community in shambles - Companies losing Linux focus - Core system components reaching sustainability - Google buildin
by smoldesu 5y ago
Their summary:
- Founders banished
- Community in shambles
- Companies losing Linux focus
- Core system components reaching sustainability
- Google building replacement
- Statistically unlikely to stay active much longer
- dnautics 5y agoI don't want to put words in Lunduke's mouth, but since it seems to be a politically charged issue, I think that in this video the perspective of why "Founders banished" matters has nothing to do with whether or not you agree with why any given one of them (or all of them) have been banished, the fact that it's all happening at once - whether or not it's a coincidence - suggests a bad future for the ecosystem.
- lavabiopsy 5y agoI disagree, out-of-touch founders being kicked out is a good thing. It's a sign that the community is strong enough and can move forward irrespective of any one person's opinion. This video has it totally backwards. Like, I get that there is an aspect of founder worship on this forum but there is no inherent value in this beyond the idea that someone can keep control indefinitely, which doesn't matter for an open source project. Maybe it matters if you want to hang onto your company's bank accounts but that's a fundamentally different thing compared to a project that exists entirely on public github.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoYou may have a point in theory, but the harsh reality seems to disagree. Kicking out stupid people may be all good and dandy, but I'm very wary of the people who are harsh proponents of the kicking, whom they represent, and what they stand for. Oh, and what/whom they suggest the "stupid" leader X should be replaced with. Usually their thinking doesn't go that far. The usual pattern I see is: employees at large corporations attacking people who don't have a big corporate affiliation. This may not mean much, but it makes me start thinking about this big picture. And then, I haven't yet seen an open source project where the long-time leader went away because of burnout of some kind or was kicked out, and it started growing, prospering, and kicking ass in general (Python doesn't count, since Guido never really went away). I've seen stagnation at best, and disuse, lack of maintenance, and a fall into obscurity in the vast majority of cases. In other words, there is not enough laissez-faire in "the community" at large to keep the tragedy of commons at bay.
- lavabiopsy 5y ago>employees at large corporations attacking people who don't have a big corporate affiliation That's interesting because on this forum I have seen quite a lot of the exact opposite: employees at startups attacking big corporation employees, seemingly because they (incorrectly) perceive them as their competitors. In fact any time Facebook, Google, Amazon or Microsoft seems to get brought up here in an article there is a barrage of negative comments and airing of grievances out of the blue. Honestly to me this is all just shades of the same open source drama, it really doesn't matter in the end who stands for what or represents what. Some people just won't get along and that's what the community has to deal with. When it's a prominent founder causing issues, then it becomes a problem for everyone.
- dnautics 5y agoI agree that kicking out out-of-touch founders is a good thing. But let's not conflate a value judgement with a prediction: When it happens all at once it says that there's either something wrong with the zeitgeist or something wrong with the leadership, or something anyways which is a leading indicator of the end.
- lavabiopsy 5y agoOr maybe it's just a coincidence? Please be careful not to get drawn into "doomsday" thinking.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- factorialboy 5y agoQuite verbose for such limited content. Anyway, Linux has always been the under-dog. It was "statistically" much less likely to survive in the late-90s and early-00s. In my personal opinion, Linux offers me the best desktop experience today. I think I'm not in a bubble, I dabble with MacOS and Windows often. Linux feels liberating. It takes time to customize to one's preferences, but after that, it is smooth AF.
- dnautics 5y ago> It takes time to customize to one's preferences I don't even do that. I find the {mint, PopOS} defaults to be incredibly sane. I think I changed the background of mint. I'm always SO very confused when I need to use a MacOS or Windows machine. That said, you can get the feeling out of the corner of your usage that something's gonna give. There has been painful transitionary stuff going on (remember X vs wayland? ifupdown vs networkmanager vs netplan? systemd? musl vs glibc?) that somehow the community papered over in a sane fashion for GP use, but when I was "sysadminnnig" stuff as an accessory to the stuff I was coding, it was loads of pain normalizing between different machines and moving from distro to distro. This could get even worse as stuff moves to containerized work, so the people most likely to complain due to bearing the most pain just stop caring.
- jbhouse 5y agothe bluetooth can be annoyingly wonky at times for me, but otherwise Linux is definitely the best in my experience
- handrous 5y ago> Anyway, Linux has always been the under-dog. It's currently dominant on phones and servers. Google can snap its fingers and set one of those on a course to drop toward zero over a few years, and is well-positioned to push Fuchsia for cloud-related server purposes if it so chooses, so that'll likely go too, if they decide to do that. AFAIK most Linux desktops are ChromeOS devices, and that's Google again. That leaves traditional Linux desktop users, but if Fuchsia's GUI is any good and is well-integrated, and driver support is OK, those'll bleed to Fuchsia faster than they're replaced, too.
- at_a_remove 5y agoThis thing with the founders is interesting (remind me to make my own license with "I take it all down with me if you destroy me" clause), but I want to know much more. But who/what is the attack vector? Is it a coordinated attack and if so, what is the method and who are the backers? Are there other founders included in this trend? Granted, those three are pretty big but ...
- dnautics 5y agoI'm not sure it matters... Even if it was completely uncoordinated or by accident, it's not good for the ecosystem.
- at_a_remove 5y agoI would disagree. If it were coordinated, it could possibly be exposed and countered.
- dnautics 5y agothat's a fair assessment, but it's also already happened, so, even if the outcomes are reversible, it's still a bad "leading indicator", as it were.
- Melkman 5y agoIf it were a coordinated attack then the chance of successfully countering it with a loosely knit community would have been be slim at best.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoI think the loosely knit community in question has already lost.
- krapp 5y agoIt's always either Marxist feminists or agent provocateurs for proprietary software. Or both.
- na85 5y ago>Founders banished Linus was banished?
- Melkman 5y agoNot yet. There were some hot headed debates during the height of #metoo about his communication style including calls for him to change his ways or stand down. Linus choose to change his ways and change the code of conflict to the code of conduct. https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/commit/?id=8a104f8b5867c682d994ffa7a74093c54469c11f https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/lin...
- na85 5y agoSo the founder of Linux wasn't banished. Got it.
- pjmlp 5y agoNot yet, although the golden question is what will happen to Linux, once all key people are no longer around. Most likely I will even be gone first, but still like most companies, it won't survive a couple of generation changes at the commanding wheel.
- Saptarishi 5y agoHe's always had that super-aggressive, rude style in discussions. Linus is not a fairy, but he is super smart.
- gHosts 5y agoHint: The community has always been in shambles. It's a feature, not a bug. Founders aren't banished, they aren't in any gulag. They can carry on. If they produce something better, they are still the drivers. A commentator below said, "remind me to make my own license with "I take it all down with me if you destroy me" clause.... That is explicitly _not_ and open source license. The point is no one, neither the founders, nor any that may replace them, "take it all down with me". You may get a fork, well then, may the best fork win. A while back gcc was forked. Remember egcs? It was the best fork for awhile. Then the fork merged again with gcc again. Yup. It happens. Life moves on.
- trav4225 5y agoYeah, this is almost like criticizing democracy for being messy. The mess is sort of the point. :-)
- tored 5y agoBryan Lunduke makes some really good points especially regarding Google, that Google eventually will replace Linux. It is worrying how Google eats up every market and at the same time branding their actions as good will, "hey it is open source!" If the US ever wants to keep some of their liberties they need to break up Google. For Europe, we need to build our own web platforms without the American big tech.
- oytis 5y agoEuropean search engines and social networks do exist, they are just not very competitive even on the European market